Log in

View Full Version : Be glad you don't live in Japan Friday


Cleo
2011-03-11, 02:05 PM
Can't believe that no one has started a morning thread yet...

Woke up around 6 this morning due to my leg bothering me. Didn't want to wake Christy up by turning on the TV so started surfing the boards and found out about Japan's monster earthquake over on GFY.

Did Foxy's updates this morning and then finished up my sports blog (http://sportserotica.info/) after doing a quick TGP gallery. Getting ready to take care of today's linkspun trades and then doing a free site in addition to the rest of today's mundane tasks.

RedCherry
2011-03-11, 02:39 PM
I was thinking the same thing. (as far as starting the morning thread)

I saw my sister post on FB about the earthquake, I just can't imagine what that was like.

Just building my second free site and getting ready to submit it while my cat wanders over and sits on my mouse while I type this, lol.

Have a good one all, and stay earthquake/Tsumani free.

JustRobert
2011-03-11, 03:19 PM
Good Morning :)
Watched live coverage of the earthquake/tsunami while working to about 1am. It was impressive to say the least. When I went to bed predictions were not good for Hawaii so glad to see they are OK.

Took care of taxes yesterday. Worse then I thought it was going to be, oh joy. Need to work, work, work to cover those taxes. Later will be a movie with wife.

ArtWilliams
2011-03-11, 03:20 PM
I often start the morning thread but I am getting ready for Hawaii. Apparently, it is still there. I will be visiting the boards but later in the day (EST) due to the five hour time difference. Time to talk to the house sitter.

Have a great day! |thumb

pc
2011-03-11, 03:46 PM
Good afternoon everyone |waves|
I started working on something different for me, little wb resource, mostly around porn industry. I don't know what I'm doing yet but I'm doing something |loony|

Can't believe that no one has started a morning thread yet...

....

http://t2.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcRhlJlTtUpf0ADgtPTV50mC9l3nMn1Pt3g4z6mdtcLxbGmEOeZDoA (http://www.google.com/imgres?imgurl=http://www.ipm.iastate.edu/ipm/icm/files/images/honey-bee-hive_0.jpg&imgrefurl=http://www.ipm.iastate.edu/ipm/icm/node/614&usg=__KNmtEtnktaccb_znLIYTWlMfmCk=&h=672&w=504&sz=64&hl=en&start=0&zoom=1&tbnid=IdxSliz82YSHMM:&tbnh=123&tbnw=94&ei=5Ht6TYW5IqSZ0QHAu_WABA&prev=/images%3Fq%3Dbee%2Bhive%26hl%3Den%26client%3Dfirefox-a%26hs%3Dt78%26sa%3DX%26rls%3Dorg.mozilla:en-US:official%26biw%3D1280%26bih%3D582%26tbs%3Disch:1%26prmd%3Divnscm&itbs=1&iact=hc&vpx=326&vpy=91&dur=1464&hovh=259&hovw=194&tx=91&ty=139&oei=5Ht6TYW5IqSZ0QHAu_WABA&page=1&ndsp=21&ved=1t:429,r:1,s:0)
everyone is working, too busy, busy, busy, busy :)

Bill
2011-03-11, 09:32 PM
The nuclear power plants are particularly interesting - not sure if I read right, but it seemed like every one of them is damaged and leaking radioactivity.

terry
2011-03-11, 10:41 PM
Happy Friday Everyone. ugh whats this world coming to???!!!!!

The Epic
2011-03-12, 12:11 AM
Late posting for me, but hope everyones Friday was very productive. I was able to get a load of work done as it was my day off.

Cleo
2011-03-12, 12:22 AM
The nuclear power plants are particularly interesting - not sure if I read right, but it seemed like every one of them is damaged and leaking radioactivity.
That is what I'm hearing too.

Naturally the anti nuclear people are already using this as an example of why no more should be built... because burning fossil fuels are so much better I guess.

dunc
2011-03-12, 06:04 AM
Yeah - the one thing I noticed is how much more "Stuff" (debris I suppose) was in the Tsunami wave - in the 2006 Indonesian Tsunami, images and video didn't have as much stuff.

Did any one see the whirlpool vid (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sU8zyscGWe4)?

Dodgy stuff though, thoughts go out for anyone involved.

Bill
2011-03-12, 08:46 AM
Naturally the anti nuclear people are already using this as an example of why no more should be built... because burning fossil fuels are so much better I guess.

Chances are good that many if not all of them are nearing the end of their projected lifespan, and may have to be decomissioned after this.

We should be replacing that style of reactor/generator with newer models anyway.

But yeah you are right, the unthoughtful greens will be all "NO NUKES" about this, unwilling to face the fact that the "no nukes" path requires a massive dieback, just as much as the "burn all the fossil carbon" path.

Not that the nuclear path is all roses. There are no great options left to us after wasting the last 40 years in an amnesiac consumption frenzy.

tickler
2011-03-12, 01:16 PM
Chances are good that many if not all of them are nearing the end of their projected lifespan, and may have to be decomissioned after this.

We should be replacing that style of reactor/generator with newer models anyway.

But yeah you are right, the unthoughtful greens will be all "NO NUKES" about this, unwilling to face the fact that the "no nukes" path requires a massive dieback, just as much as the "burn all the fossil carbon" path.

Not that the nuclear path is all roses. There are no great options left to us after wasting the last 40 years in an amnesiac consumption frenzy.
If I read right those are the Canadian reactors, which are somewhat safer than the American fast-breeder types! |tomato|

Not that a lot of things would stand up to an earthquake which was 8,000 times stronger than the one that just leveled Christchurch! |loony|


Fossil Fuels on Demand
In September, a privately held and highly secretive U.S. biotech company named Joule Unlimited received a patent for “a proprietary organism” – a genetically engineered cyanobacterium that produces liquid hydrocarbons: diesel fuel, jet fuel and gasoline. This breakthrough technology, the company says, will deliver renewable supplies of liquid fossil fuel almost anywhere on Earth, in essentially unlimited quantity and at an energy-cost equivalent of $30 (U.S.) a barrel of crude oil.

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/opinions/opinion/a-brave-new-world-of-fossil-fuels-on-demand/article1871149/
We will have to see how this new gem plays out! |whisper| |thumb
a) - [ ] Oil companies deep six it
b) - [ ] Gets wild & devours all carbon

Bill
2011-03-12, 07:16 PM
I couldn't say, I haven't looked at all into the design of the japanese reactors.

It's a fascinating experiment tho - what happens to a nuclear plant in an earthquake. And how do you repair a reactor after an earthquake, lol.

An expensive experiment I bet

Seems an odd choice, putting reactors on the ring of fire. But we got em in california, also on the ring of fire.

---

Who knows about algal biodiesel. One hears this claim and that claim. But one sees no appreciable stream of algal biodeisel flowing.

Same with cellulosic ethanol.

$30 a barrel sounds real nice. Seems that is it were true, at $100 oil, somebody would be building some algal biodiesel plants.

I'm not holding my breath. Our energy supply system is crazy, and we humans have been fucking up on energy pretty consistently.

Three years ago we had an energy shock that should have started a real self-examination - but we did nothing but heave a sigh of relief when an economic collapse temporarily dropped the price of oil.

So here we are again, not really one step further down the road, except our economy lost trillions which it might have spent on developing alternatives to fossil carbons.

Cleo
2011-03-13, 12:18 AM
Doesn't seem like building it so close to the ocean was a good idea.

Also it doesn't look like there is a containment dome over the reactor.

Bill
2011-03-13, 07:37 PM
MSNBC says The Fukushima nuclear plants have 23 sisters in the US (http://openchannel.msnbc.msn.com/_news/2011/03/13/6256121-general-electric-designed-reactors-in-fukushima-have-23-sisters-in-us)


The NRC database of nuclear power plants (http://www.nrc.gov/reactors/operating/list-power-reactor-units.html) shows that 23 of the 104 nuclear plants in the U.S. are GE boiling-water reactors with GE's Mark I systems for containing radioactivity, the same containment system used by the reactors in trouble at the Fukushima Daiichi plant. The U.S. reactors are in Alabama, Georgia, Illinois, Iowa, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Nebraska, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Pennsylvania and Vermont.
In addition, 12 reactors in the U.S. have the later Mark II or Mark III containment system from GE. These 12 are in Illinois, Louisiana, Mississippi, New York, Ohio, Pennsylvania and Washington state. See the full list below.


So I guess the japanese are running an experiment in stress testing that kind of plant for us.

Cleo
2011-03-13, 08:13 PM
A quick search on Google images found this. Doesn't look like a dome to me. More like a factory building.

http://www.nucleartourist.com/imagemaps/rx-bldg1.jpg

Voltar
2011-03-13, 08:34 PM
and they now have upped the death count to over 10k and climbing with over a 100k already fled from Japan...what a horrible thing to happen! so many long term effects are going to be felt there for years to come...they are also now saying it's the worst thing to happen since WWII and the bomb dropped on them..looks like to me it could turn out to be worse than that for them if things keep going sideways at the reactors there...

Cleo
2011-03-14, 01:19 PM
I found this site today with some good info on what is taking place.
http://www.nei.org/newsandevents/information-on-the-japanese-earthquake-and-reactors-in-that-region/

Linkster
2011-03-14, 09:16 PM
In my "other life" I am in radiation protection - and first off - the info from NEI that Cleo posted is a good overview of what is really going on without the sensationalist journalism that unfortunately the media has been dipping in lately.(again???)

The dose rates that they list being double normal site levels are probably in the reactor building/containment and although a little higher than normal, not something that would have an effect on the outside world.(It just affects how you do your recovery inside the plant as you have to take extra protective measures)

The precautionary distrubution of Potassium Iodide is very conservative in my opinion, as there has been very little released during the hydrogen explosions - and is more than likely just a political move to calm fears. And for you hunters out there if you like your venison - you eat more cesium in your meat than anyone came close to inhaling at Three Mile Island :)

One statement in an earlier post kinda rubbed me the wrong way, as while there are a few plants in the US of the same design, they all have been changed since they were built because of the accident at TMI ages ago....the hydrogen buildup that occurred in Japan would not have happened in the US...all of the plants installed hydrogen recombiners that basically turn the excess hydrogen back into water vapor...as this was the same issue that TMI had when they had their explosion.
The US plants also revamped their core cooling systems to not require any type of power to inject water and "poison"(boron) that would keep the reactor covered and shut down till it was in cold shutdown (about 36 hours).

Cleo - in your picture you are correct - it is not a "dome" but the common term for the concrete layers just above and around the yellow colored spere in the center is called a dome since on other designs it is dome shaped. The rust red colored cylinder in the center is the reactor vessel which encloses the fuel and is where the water is boiled. The yellow cover above that is called the "drywell" head. That section is immersed in a pool of water which is the likely source of the creation of the hydrogen in these Japanese plants. When water gets irradiated it separates into hydrogen and oxygen. The hydrogen forms pockets after it vents into the atmosphere of the upper building where they show a crane (orange and yellow at the top in your picture) Anything that can cause a spark (theres lots of electrical panels in there) will light off the hydrogen and blow the roof and walls off that building - which is what you are seeing in all of the explosion pics and vids you see on the net.

The reactor vessel in the center (again the red cylinder) is more than likely still intact on these plants containing the fuel even if there were damage to the fuel. Even at TMI the fuel was in the bottom of that vessel - and while the news loves the term "meltdown" - the damaged fuel just piles up at the bottom of that vessel and stays there - hopefully one of these days we can educate the media to let them know that the fuel isnt going to go anywhere else like it does in the movies.

For those of you wondering about radiation dose if you have any questions Ill check in here and will be glad to answer anything - however I may disappoint if you are looking for sensationalism as even at TMI - the dose to the press corps who wanted to stay right at the fence to film what was going on was 1/10th of what they would have gotten getting one side of a dental xray. They got more radiation dose flying to the site in a plane from cosmic rays than they did sitting outside the plant for weeks on end misinforming the public :)

Cleo
2011-03-14, 10:47 PM
I do find it somewhat amusing how the US has gone from dropping two atomic bombs on Japan that killed over 100,000 people almost instantly to complete hysteria over a small amount of radiation.

Doesn't Japan still have high levels of radiation where the A-bombs were dropped and people are living in these cities now?

I remember getting my brand new Datsun 240Z in 1973 and seeing that it was made in Hiroshima.

Cleo
2011-03-15, 12:26 AM
Did a bit of Goggling... seems that radiation at the bomb sites quickly dissipated.

"Today, the background radiation in Hiroshima and Nagasaki is the same as the average amount of natural radiation present anywhere on Earth. It is not enough to affect human health."
http://www.pcf.city.hiroshima.jp/kids/KPSH_E/question_box/question12.html

And in other news mining and burning coal kills hundreds each year.

Linkster
2011-03-15, 12:58 AM
Cleo - thats correct - the radiation (actually what we call contamination) dissipates very quickly - the primary nuclides released during an atom bomb explosion last a few hours with some small amounts lasting longer and getting deposited worldwide - thats why I mentioned the deer hunters earlier - they are still eating cesium left over from the atomic tests of the 1950s in the soil/plants

The news media (and hence the people that are listening seem to confuse things as well)

Contamination is the actual material that gets blown airborne - radiation is the energy that comes from it - the way I use to explain to my students was that if you step in a pile of dog poop - the poop on your shoe is the contamination and the smell is the radiation emitted from that material.

You will hear stories where people are showered after being contaminated (although the news will say they washed radiation off of them which is actually totally impossible - it would be like taking a shower to wash off light after youve been outside)

Bill
2011-03-16, 07:21 PM
Ahhh, I didn't know this, tho could have guessed.

Turns out using seawater (doped with boron) to cool those reactors ruins them.

So, a very expensive experiment indeed.

http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=japan-earthquake-tsunami-nuclear-seawater&WT.mc_id=SA_DD_20110316

As the situation at Japan's 40-year-old Fukushima Daiichi nuclear plant (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fukushima%20I%20Nuclear%20Power%20Plant) goes from bad to worse—four of the plant's six boiling-water (http://www.scientificamerican.com/topic.cfm?id=water) reactors have been damaged by explosions or fire, and radiation has begun leaking into the atmosphere—officials there continue to pump seawater into the reactors in a desperate attempt to cool down fuel rods and avoid a complete meltdown that could release radioactive fallout across much of the country and beyond. The move by Tokyo Electric Power Co. (TEPCO), which operates Daiichi, to use seawater doped with neutron-absorbing boron in the reactors' pressure vessels all but ensures that they will never function properly again, permanently damaging one of the world's 25 largest nuclear power (http://www.scientificamerican.com/topic.cfm?id=nuclear-power) stations.



40 years old - I thought so - which means they were likely close to their projected useful life already.

So what we are seeing is the beginning of the largest decommisioning project on the planet.

Cleo
2011-03-16, 07:30 PM
Have you seen the close-up pics released today? Sea water would seem to be a least of the worries as they looked more like a big pile of rubble than a power plant.

Not sure how much of the news is spin but listening to the news today things it sure seems like Japan is just totally fucked.

Bill
2011-03-16, 08:15 PM
Imagining the conditions that the "faceless 50" must be working in is an exercise in science fiction, for sure.

Ironic that two energy-related disasters - the gulf spill and now a nuclear plant meltdown - should happen in consecutive years. A reminder of what can happen to complex systems under stress.

The photos look pretty disastery, but I can't say what they are really showing us. The outer shells of the buildings are beat to shit - but it's what we can't see that is the interesting part.

Here's where we all start making godzilla jokes.

Linkster
2011-03-16, 10:27 PM
So far what has been found by the American teams that are on-site there is that NO reactors have been damaged - most of them didnt have fuel in them anyway at the two sites the news has been covering.

The real issue is that the fuel they took out of those reactors some time ago has to sit in pools called spent fuel pools to keep them covered.

At one plant the spent fuel pool was damaged and all water is gone out of the pool (including the boron that is normally in the pool dissolved in the water) and they have no way to get any water back into it right now - there is no fire associated with that.
A second spent fuel pool is looking like it also was damaged and lost its water - but that is not certain yet.

The explosions and fires that have reduced the other buildings to rubble are not the reactor buildings - they are called auxiliary buildings and house the backup equipment on the outside of the reactor building.
All reactor buildings are intact with the exception of the one above that has no water in the spent fuel pool - that building has lost its last boundary and the dose rates from direct radiation from the fuel is very high.

The US NRC did take the precautionary step of evacuating all US citizens for 50 miles outside the confirmed damaged aux building today.

Remember also that the news is talking about nuclear plants without even telling anyone that this is actually two different sites in different cities

The fires after the hydrogen explosions (gas explosions which are non-radioactive) have been caused by the flammable oil storage tanks and the oil in the pumps being used to try to get water to the spent fuel pools.

Bill
2011-03-16, 10:43 PM
Why does the sciam page say that the seawater/boron mix damages the reactors?

What happens to the seawater pumped into the reactors? Presumably afterwards it contains some amount of contaminant, possibly at dangerous levels.

Linkster
2011-03-17, 12:46 AM
The stainless steel used to line the reactors will be destroyed by the chlorides (salt) in the seawater which will make the reactors unusable in the future = with the temperatures and pressures that a reactor operates at, the corrosion levels from salt can eat through stainless in a matter of hours

Linkster
2011-03-17, 12:48 AM
Bill - also as far as I know, no one has even come close to pumping boron or seawater into any of the reactors - the seawater cooling approach was only going to be used for the spent fuel pools (storage for old fuel) - I have not been able to find any reliable sources that say that there was ever a lack of water in any of the reactors and it would have surprised me if they had lost any water in those designs

Linkster
2011-03-17, 12:59 AM
Just an update - the spent fuel pools I was mentioning earlier have been confirmed to have water in them (which is great news) and while the temperature is a little higher than normal its not anything that cant be controlled easily.

All of the other reactors are doing fine and are shutdown and cooled down - at both plant sites in Japan - with the exception of one unit (#3) at the Daiichi site that is currently being sprayed from copters with cooling water to control the temperature and avoid damage to the reactor.

tickler
2011-03-17, 11:51 AM
I still like the ideal of these mini-nuclear plants!

$25 million, 20,000 homes. at about $0.10/kwh, and the size of a garden shed!

Self-contained units, factory built, not major security item, swappable modules, and can be used at location without upgrades to the grid.

http://www.physorg.com/news145561984.html

Cleo
2011-03-17, 12:06 PM
I still think the huge concrete containment domes over US nuclear plants in the US, like the ones at Turkey Point (http://www.fpl.com/environment/nuclear/pdf/security.pdf) south of me, offer far more protection than the secondary steel vessels around the Japanese ones. I know that I don't worry about the ones south of me and hope they go ahead with plans to add two more (http://www.fpl.com/environment/nuclear/faq.shtml).


http://www.physorg.com/news145561984.html
That look great but I'm not sure that the public would ever go for it.

Toby
2011-03-17, 12:50 PM
...I don't worry about the ones south of me and hope they go ahead with plans to add two more.

The only issue I have with building more nuclear plants is the disposal of the spent fuel. They still haven't figured that out, and in the mean time, it sits in pools accumulating.

Cleo
2011-03-17, 01:31 PM
The only issue I have with building more nuclear plants is the disposal of the spent fuel. They still haven't figured that out, and in the mean time, it sits in pools accumulating.
I think there is already a solution, big hole deep underground, but the public won't agree on anything so as a result it sits in "temporally" pools.

Bill
2011-03-17, 08:26 PM
The small format reactors are interesting, but I've yet to see really convincing working prototypes - has anyone else?

I thought the pebble bed reactor concept was interesting too.

As I understood it tho, uranium is the limiting factor for a nuclear electricity economy. There's enough uranium for a while, but of we wanted to produce planetary scale amounts of nuclear electricity the struggle for uranium would relatively quickly mirror the current competition for oil.

The proposed solution is a plutonium economy based on breeder reactors - and a plutonium economy has a lot of scary problems asscoiated with it.

Linkster
2011-03-17, 10:47 PM
The only issue I have with building more nuclear plants is the disposal of the spent fuel. They still haven't figured that out, and in the mean time, it sits in pools accumulating.

Actually most plants have instituted their own storage vaults on-site that gets the fuel out of the pools into a dry storage cask

Linkster
2011-03-17, 10:55 PM
I still like the ideal of these mini-nuclear plants!

$25 million, 20,000 homes. at about $0.10/kwh, and the size of a garden shed!

Self-contained units, factory built, not major security item, swappable modules, and can be used at location without upgrades to the grid.

http://www.physorg.com/news145561984.html

Unfortunately they fail to mention that if you had one of these in an earthquake of a magnitude of about 5 and up you would crack the concrete and have a worse dispersal of material than they have in Japan right now - and I tend to believe that Homeland Security would have some real issues with these :)

JK
2011-03-18, 09:43 AM
I'm by no means an expert in nuclear power, and my country is responsible for a fair amount of natural atrocities that I have no control over (mining, burning coal, not to mention exporting uranium), but I watched a documentary a few months ago outlining the benefits of nuclear fusion, which sounds like a much cleaner energy source than fission, that has if I remember correctly no waste and an unheard of efficency ratio.

If you don't mind me asking Linkster, why isn't more money being spent on researching other types of nuclear power, rather than trying to fix a shit one, for lack of a better word. This is of course, based on my very limited knowledge on the subject.

Cleo
2011-03-18, 10:59 AM
Turns out that the moon has a plentiful supply of helium 3 that I've read would make fusion practical.

LD
2011-03-18, 01:30 PM
I too am intrigued by fusion. I had thought that fission was just a precursor to fusion. My concern is that big energy sources get somewhat institutionalized, like oil. It becomes very hard to progress to a better alternative, usually because of big financial stakes in the status quo. Oligopolies and monopolies have a way of digging in and become extremely resistant to change.

Bill
2011-03-18, 07:16 PM
We are not significantly close to practical fusion as a commercial energy source. They've been stalled for a while. Inching forward with magnetic containment systems and laser ignition and other interesting technologies, but even if we crash poured trillions into development there's no reason to believe they will crack the problem.

You got the new "cold fusion" guys, but while one hears curious rumors it seems just as likely that's just a gimmick or a noncommercial effect, and nodody I know of in the energy industries is willing to say "well, we should look at it".

I always hoped for fusion too.

There are all kinds of interesting research projects going on - I keep hoping one or more of the promises will come to fruition. But year after year goes by and none of the promises makes it to the marketplace in any practical way.

Yesterday metafilter linked to the wave disk engine. (http://nextbigfuture.com/2011/03/wave-disk-engines-could-be-35-times.html) Sounds great, right? Well over the years I've seen many such things that sounded great, but they never come to the market.

Magnetohydrodynamics for example - one of my all time faves - huge news in the energy community years ago - never came to anything.

Recently I saw an article about a carbon dioxide based supercritical fluid generator that sounded like it might be based on magnetohydrodynamics, or at least an improved phase-change turbine. Sounds great. An alternative to the steam turbine. Will we ever see it? I bet we won't.

Linkster
2011-03-18, 11:36 PM
JK - fusion first of all is being researched heavily right now but the technology has not been refined enough to make it useful for probably at least 50 years - there is a group of countries right now pouring alot of money into the research in the ITER reactor project currently underway. The problem so far has been that all experiments have required more energy input to the reactor and systems than you produce. The ITER project has claimed that they believe they can produce power at 10 times the input power.

In answer to the amount of money being spent - more money is spent on fusion research than any other energy research currently

The concept that there is no waste to deal with is not true - you still have radioactive waste - the difference is that it decays in about 300 years (which is about the same length of time it takes the radioactive waste from a coal buring plant to decay) vs. the 10,000 years or so from the fission process.

The last issue is that most environmental groups and anti-nukes will have issues with the tritium that leaks from fusion reactors since it is even an issue right now in groundwater from many other industries including fission. Tritium is usally dismissed by most people as a harmless waste, however if you ingest it or absorb it through the skin it is much more damaging to the body than most other nuclides we deal with in fission plants - and tritium is very abundent in fusion :)

An example I guess I could make would be that if a fusion plant was located in Japan during the earthquake and flooding, you would have significant issues from the resulting magnet explosions, tritium releases etc that would probably kill way more people than anything all of these fission reactors will do....during Three Mile Island (which is the closest type of release compared to the Japanese plant releases) there were exactly 0 deaths caused and the risk of cancer rose by less than if each one of the people in Pennsylvania had smoked one cigarette

RedCherry
2011-03-19, 01:25 PM
Saw this posted up on the current radiation levels that have been measured, and how long you would have to be exposed to to them to equal common radiation exposure.

http://www.cbryanjones.com/journal/2011/3/19/japan-radiation-levels-in-english.html

Linkster
2011-03-19, 04:41 PM
Thats actually an excellent comparison - although in the US we use a different (non-intl unit) measurement system which is in millirem and rem (1000 mrem = 1 Rem)

the micro sieverts he uses on the map equate to our units of measurement by using 1 mrem = 10 micro sieverts

The legal limit the nuclear industry workers in the US are allowed per year is 5000 mrem, although none come even close - the highest Ive ever received in one year is around 2000 mrem.

The natural background we see in the US at sea level is about 310 mRem per year - 40 mRem comes from your own bones (potassium is radioactive) and another 310 mRem from the average xrays, medical and commercial/industrial operations(smoke detectors, exit signs above doors etc etc)
If you happen to live in Denver you obviously would get more since you are closer to the cosmic radiation coming in from space - and flying gets you a little more each flight.

A good read for the US background is:
http://www.nrc.gov/reading-rm/doc-collections/fact-sheets/bio-effects-radiation.html

The levels outside of the worst damaged plant in Japan is somewhere between 2 and 4 mRem per hour if you were standing at the fence constantly.

In comparison - the worst radiation levels anyone was exposed to at Three Mile Island was at the fence and it was 1 mRem per hour - at the height of the accident - and then tapered off to background levels after a few hours. Of course the only people close to the fence were the news media and they had to be shooed away to make sure they didnt get that extra 1 mRem since they aren't evidently capable of learning anything about nuclear power :)

tickler
2011-03-20, 12:02 PM
Unfortunately they fail to mention that if you had one of these in an earthquake of a magnitude of about 5 and up you would crack the concrete and have a worse dispersal of material than they have in Japan right now - and I tend to believe that Homeland Security would have some real issues with these :)
I'll have to take your expert advice on that, but I do believe that they are sealed metal units!

As far as Homeland Security, as mentioned in the article, you would have to break into the area, use heavy equipment to dig the unit up, break into the actual unit itself, and deal with a small amount of material that is "too hot(temperature wise) to handle" manually! People might just happen to notice this going on!

Also, the material is so low grade, you would need massive amounts, and massive technology to upgrade it! |huh



I come from an uranium mining & processing part of the country, and radiation levels are constantly monitored! Studies show that nuclear workers tend to be exposed to about half the radiation as normal people!

Perhaps because of protective work gear, working in "shielded" areas, more caution about X-rays/CTs, etc.
http://www.brucepower.com/docs/Topic%201%20-%20Understanding%20Radiation%20August%2026.pdf

Actually in one small processing town, the cancer rate is lower than average population, and the cancer rate for nuclear employees working there is lower even than the rate for the town! |crazy|


That sort of ties in with family history(living in a uranium mining area) where almost nobody seems to die from cancer, although there are the other normal medical problems! We just blame it on constant radiation theraphy from the slightly higher background radiation! There are some actual long term studies of my family being conducted about this effect! |whisper|

Linkster
2011-03-20, 06:05 PM
I'd have to see exactly what they submit to the NRC (if they ever do) to see the design but I tend to believe that some of their claims are already impossible (like no moving parts - when they say they use turbines to produce electrical energy - impossible to do with no moving parts)

They claim on their website that the unit is enclosed in concrete which is why I made the comment - also the uraniom that is used in the fission process wouldnt just be "hot" thermally - it would be instantly fatal if exposed to it - the enrichment figures they talk about are not much different than you see in a University reactor at colleges in the US.

The low level exposure studies are something Ive been following for a long time - seems that most researchers come to the conclusion that some small amounts of exposure are beneficial - while others claim that "any" exposure has a risk - seems kind of weird since the body is a source of radiation from the bones naturally (Potassium).

Cleo
2011-03-20, 06:32 PM
With all the bananas that I eat I must be a radioactive hazard.

Bill
2011-03-23, 03:34 AM
I kinda liked what George Monbiot had to say.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2011/mar/21/pro-nuclear-japan-fukushima


You will not be surprised to hear that the events in Japan (http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/japan) have changed my view of nuclear power. You will be surprised to hear how they have changed it. As a result of the disaster at Fukushima, I am no longer nuclear-neutral. I now support the technology.

A crappy old plant with inadequate safety features was hit by a monster earthquake and a vast tsunami. The electricity supply failed, knocking out the cooling system. The reactors began to explode and melt down. The disaster exposed a familiar legacy of poor design and corner-cutting. Yet, as far as we know, no one has yet received a lethal dose of radiation.

Some greens have wildly exaggerated the dangers of radioactive pollution. For a clearer view, look at the graphic published by xkcd.com (http://blog.xkcd.com/2011/03/19/radiation-chart/). It shows that the average total dose from the Three Mile Island (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_Mile_Island_accident) disaster for someone living within 10 miles of the plant was one 625th of the maximum yearly amount permitted for US radiation workers. This, in turn, is half of the lowest one-year dose clearly linked to an increased cancer risk, which, in its turn, is one 80th of an invariably fatal exposure. I'm not proposing complacency here. I am proposing perspective.

If other forms of energy production caused no damage, these impacts would weigh more heavily. But energy is like medicine: if there are no side-effects, the chances are that it doesn't work.

Like most greens, I favour a major expansion of renewables. I can also sympathise with the complaints of their opponents. It's not just the onshore windfarms that bother people, but also the new grid connections (pylons and power lines). As the proportion of renewable electricity on the grid rises, more pumped storage will be needed to keep the lights on. That means reservoirs on mountains: they aren't popular, either.

The impacts and costs of renewables rise with the proportion of power they supply, as the need for storage and redundancy increases. It may well be the case (I have yet to see a comparative study) that up to a certain grid penetration – 50% or 70%, perhaps? – renewables have smaller carbon impacts than nuclear, while beyond that point, nuclear has smaller impacts than renewables.

Like others, I have called for renewable power to be used both to replace the electricity produced by fossil fuel and to expand the total supply, displacing the oil used for transport and the gas used for heating fuel. Are we also to demand that it replaces current nuclear capacity? The more work we expect renewables to do, the greater the impact on the landscape will be, and the tougher the task of public persuasion.

But expanding the grid to connect people and industry to rich, distant sources of ambient energy is also rejected by most of the greens who complained about the blog post I wrote last week in which I argued that nuclear remains safer than coal. What they want, they tell me, is something quite different: we should power down and produce our energy locally. Some have even called for the abandonment of the grid. Their bucolic vision sounds lovely, until you read the small print.

At high latitudes like ours, most small-scale ambient power production is a dead loss. Generating solar power in the UK involves a spectacular waste of scarce resources. It's hopelessly inefficient and poorly matched to the pattern of demand. Wind power in populated areas is largely worthless. This is partly because we have built our settlements in sheltered places; partly because turbulence caused by the buildings interferes with the airflow and chews up the mechanism. Micro-hydropower might work for a farmhouse in Wales, but it's not much use in Birmingham.

And how do we drive our textile mills, brick kilns, blast furnaces and electric railways – not to mention advanced industrial processes? Rooftop solar panels? The moment you consider the demands of the whole economy is the moment at which you fall out of love with local energy production. A national (or, better still, international) grid is the essential prerequisite for a largely renewable energy supply.

Cleo
2011-03-23, 12:21 PM
Here is another one.

Fossil fuels are far deadlier than nuclear power (http://www.newscientist.com/article/mg20928053.600-fossil-fuels-are-far-deadlier-than-nuclear-power.html?DCMP=OTC-rss&nsref=online-news).

I know that I would much rather live near a nuclear power plant that one that burns fossil fuel but unfortunately I live near the oil fired one at Port Everglades (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FLNdlhNfPwU).

Bill
2011-03-28, 11:16 PM
One of the interesting possibilities. I already mentioned that we don;t have enough uranium to power an economy long term - but the thorium proponents claim we have enough thorium.

http://theweek.com/article/index/213611/could-thorium-make-nuclear-power-safe

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Why are fans so excited about it?
Thorium-fueled reactors are supposed to be much safer than uranium-powered ones, use far less material (1 metric ton of thorium gets as much bang as 200 metric tons of uranium, or 3.5 million metric tons of coal), produce waste that is toxic for a shorter period of time (300 years vs. uranium's tens of thousands of years), and is hard to weaponize. In fact, thorium can even feed off of toxic plutonium waste to produce energy. And because the biggest cost in nuclear power is safety, and thorium reactors can't melt down, argues Michael Anissimov in Accelerating Future (http://www.acceleratingfuture.com/michael/blog/2006/10/a-nuclear-reactor-in-every-home/), they will eventually be much cheaper, too.

How cheap would it be?
If a town of 1,000 bought a 1-megawatt thorium reactor for $250,000, using 20 kilograms of thorium a year with almost no oversight, every family could pay as little as $0.40 a year for all their electricity, Anissimov predicts (http://www.acceleratingfuture.com/michael/blog/2006/10/a-nuclear-reactor-in-every-home/). And small reactors like that aren't just potentially cost-effective, he says; they're much safer, too.

Where can we get thorium?
Lots of places. The U.S. has an estimated 440,000 metric tons, Australia and India have about 300,000 metric tons, and Canada has 100,000 metric tons. Until recently, U.S. and Australian mining companies threw it away as a useless byproduct. There is enough thorium to power the earth for about 1,000 years, boosters say, versus an estimated 80 years' worth of uranium.

If thorium's so great, why do we use uranium?
To make a "long story very short and simple," says The Star's Antonia Zerbisias (http://www.thestar.com/news/insight/article/960564--thorium-touted-as-the-answer-to-our-energy-needs), weapons and nuclear subs. U.S. researchers were developing both uranium-based and thorium-based reactors in the Cold War 1950s, but thorium doesn't create weapons-grade plutonium as a byproduct. Plus, nuclear submarines could be designed more easily and quickly around uranium-based light-water reactors.

OK, but there must be a downside to thorium, right?
Indeed. First, it will take a lot of money to develop a new generation of thorium-fueled reactors — America's has been dormant for half a century. China is taking the lead in picking up the thread, building on plans developed and abandoned in Europe. And part of the reason Europe dropped the research, according to critics, is pressure from France's uranium-based nuclear power industry. Others just think the whole idea is being oversold. If "an endless, too-cheap-to-meter source of clean, benign, what-could-possibly-go-wrong energy" sounds too good to be true, says nuclear analyst Norm Rubin (http://www.thestar.com/news/insight/article/960564--thorium-touted-as-the-answer-to-our-energy-needs), it's because it is.
=================================================

Cleo
2011-03-29, 12:28 AM
I want to put one in my backyard and sell power to all my neighbors. I would be Cleo's Power and Porn.