PDA

View Full Version : The BIG Bailout


Jim
2008-09-26, 11:48 AM
I have to admit I am 100% confused about spending $700 Billion to bail out wall street. And, I have been watching it very closely.

It doesn't help that Bush says we need to do it and Democrats agree. And yet, Republicans are against it. I see that it has turned very political and that was to be expected. But, who is right and who is wrong?

I would have much rather seen a new stimulus package where every US family received $5k. That would save about $200 Billion and it seems to me that it would have the same effect. Then again, there would be no chance of payback. Oh WTF..my head starts spinning when I think about it too much. :)

Anyway, being totally honest with each other, I think most of can see that when we first discussed our business as being recession proof over a year ago, those that said we would be, were wrong. But that seems to be a different discussion at this point.

So, if the taxpayers bailout wall street, will banks loosen up credit and make life go back to normal? Or, is it just a complete waste of money?

Bobc01
2008-09-26, 11:57 AM
I've been keeping an eye on it too and it looks to be a waste of money.

Why should the tax payer keep having to bail banks out of debts they risked knowing the goverment would do what they're doing now.

It was said in a news program here that banks take the risks knowing if they got in the shit the goverments would rescue them and the only way to prevent it happening again would be to regulate the banks more.

Ofcourse it won't happen because there's too much "let's say interests ;) " between banks and political parties.

Jim
2008-09-26, 12:04 PM
I agree about the "interests" but then, why are the Republicans not on board? The whole fight does seem to be politcal.

And, what happens if the bailout doesn't happen? Already people are waking up all over seeing that they no longer have a credit card. Obviously, the lack of credit cards is not good for an industry that depends so heavily on cc sales.

docholly
2008-09-26, 12:13 PM
The only way any of it would make sense would be that each 'at risk' mortgage was re-evaluated.. that an assessor would go to the house and give a "true value" to it.. not the inflated value of 2-3 years ago, then the banks would adjust accordingly. So if some fool making 65K per year bought a 500K house which at true market value would be worth 280K, then the banks would assess it at 280K, give a mortgage based on that @ whatever rate the "powers" that be come up with. I've never gotten over the fact that workers at $10-12.00/per hour thought they could actually afford a 1/2 million dollar house. Too bad if they lose their equity.. that's the price for being sooo stupid.

It's not going to do much good to just "throw" money at the existing problem. I also don't like the fact that Paulson et.al. at the Treasury would not be accountable for the billions. When the president 1st announced it, i swear I could see the Puppetmaster (cheney) holding his strings ..so they could have a grand send off with gold falling out of their pockets. I was NEVER ever a conspiracy theorist prior to Bush/Cheney..always my country..right or wrong.

With WAMU going under last night, can Wells Fargo, Citibank etc be far behind???

True Republicans believe in a market based economy, supply and demand and capitalism. less government, more states rights. Government bail out is the last thing they would want which just reinforces my long held belief that Bush/Cheney are impostors. Fake Republicans.

Something has to be done, but throwing 700 Billion dollars at the same people who caused this, might not be the answer.

JustRobert
2008-09-26, 12:30 PM
I have a problem with the bail out. My gut feeling says it is a bail out for the wealthy, again.

This just makes my head spin and there is going to be no good answers. Whatever plays out, I think in the end we are screwed.

Bobc01
2008-09-26, 12:33 PM
I agree about the "interests" but then, why are the Republicans not on board? The whole fight does seem to be politcal.

Election tactics probably knowing there's an election coming up.

I always laugh when one party opposes something then a year down the line proposes the exact same thing they were disagreeing on.


I can bet there's alot of people working hard at the moment on exploiting that money.

SirMoby
2008-09-26, 12:45 PM
True Republicans believe in a market based economy, supply and demand and capitalism. less government, more states rights. Government bail out is the last thing they would want which just reinforces my long held belief that Bush/Cheney are impostors. Fake Republicans.
Look at what the OCC in conjunction with the DOJ during 2003 -to 2005 to make sure that these bad loans stayed profitable for a short period of time.

The problem is that through new OCC auditing standards that were changed for the first time in 140 years allowed banks and hedge funds to value paper loans not even at the $500,000 value of years ago but the future estimated value of perhaps $1,000,000. While they hold a loan on a property worth $250k they could actually declare $1,000,000 in assets which would allow them to borrow 10 times that or basically 40 times what they really had.

When people wonder how Bush's daddy's company The Carlyle Group could lose so much money over night, or suddenly Bears Sterns could have $30,000,000,000 in bad debt it's not because people are defaulting, it's because the OCC allowed them to declare 30, 40 and some estimates 100 times the value of real assets.

Normally banks and funds had to have 10% to 15% in actual assets for what they were borrowing. From 2003 until now they only needed 1% to 3% so if values on that money borrowed dropped 2% these companies were broke.

I've been trying to remind people since 2000 of the S&L Crisis, the families that profited and the law makers in power. No one cared.

Greenguy
2008-09-26, 12:56 PM
Look at what the OCC...What does XXXJay have to do with any of this?























is there really a need for a |couch| down here?

JustRobert
2008-09-26, 01:12 PM
So if some fool making 65K per year bought a 500K house which at true market value would be worth 280K, then the banks would assess it at 280K, give a mortgage based on that @ whatever rate the "powers" that be come up with.

Oh No, If they were stupid enough to buy an overpriced house they should be responsible enough to pay it ALL back. Nobody forced them to buy it, it was there choice.

Nobody wants to take responsibility for their actions any more. Pisses me off |angry|

Now if the banks want to cut a deal with these stupid buyers and say extend the 30 yr mortgage to 45 or 60 yrs so it reduces the monthly cost to be more maneagable, but they still owe the $500K, so be it.

Toby
2008-09-26, 01:46 PM
There has to be a market correction at some point. It's simply inevitible. This bailout only postpones and shifts the effects of that correction. Sooner of later the price has to be paid. Until then it's all just playing games with numbers.

Ramster
2008-09-26, 02:41 PM
What SirMoby says is so true.

Banks are going under because "they are being written down" and they are being "downgraded". Being downgraded makes it impossible for them to borrow money against their assets (since the assets have been lowered in value) to get cash they need to pay immediate expenses so they go under. Regarding Washington Mutual it happened exactly like that "On Wednesday, it suffered a ratings downgrade by Standard & Poor's that put it in danger of collapse". The next day it's gone.

Regarding Jim's question. No I do not think they should do a bailout! God only knows where the fuck that money will end up. How will they monitor the money? WHere will it spent? Who authorizes the money? Bad idea all around I think. If anything set the money aside to do what they've done in recent weeks. Step in with cash to take over companies and assets.

And the taxpayers need not worry. IMO the money will not be taken from taxpayers exactly. Are they not using taxpayers money and that money will not be used elsewhere (for school, roads or where ever) until (if) it is paid back. THat part I'd like to know about for sure.

LD
2008-09-26, 06:36 PM
Deregulation and poor policy caused the mess...Why don't they talk about doing something about that? It smells too much like the Iraq war and WMDs to me.

Interesting the conservative Republicans are voicing the biggest opposition. In this case I think they are correct. Senator Shelby (R) AL is one I am not often in agreement with, but I think he's right on on this:

Secretary Paulson presented Congress with draft legislation that would grant him sweeping authority to spend up to $700 billion in taxpayer money to buy illiquid securities. The stated goal of this scheme is to return confidence and liquidity to our credit markets. I do not believe this is the right approach. We did not get into this situation in a matters of days, and we are not going to fix it in a matter of days.

http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/money_co/2008/09/republican-le-1.html

Bill
2008-09-26, 07:26 PM
Anyway, being totally honest with each other, I think most of can see that when we first discussed our business as being recession proof over a year ago, those that said we would be, were wrong. But that seems to be a different discussion at this point.

People said that?

Bwah-hah-hah-hah-choke-sputter-cough.

But you're right, thats a whole nuther discussion.

---

I thought what Ben Stein said about credit default swaps being the real problem, the HUGE problem hidden behind the mortgage bailout, is relevant.

http://finance.yahoo.com/expert/article/yourlife/109609

"Here s one big part of the answer. First, the alert reader will notice that Ben Stein said many times that the amount of money at risk in the subprime meltdown was just not enough to sink an economy of this size. And I was right...to a point. The amount of subprime that defaulted was at most - after recovery in liquidation - about $250 billion. A huge sum but not enough to torpedo the US economy.

The crisis occurred (to greatly oversimplify) because the financial system allowed entities to place bets on whether or not those mortgages would ever be paid. You didn't have to own a mortgage to make the bets. These bets, called Credit Default Swaps, are complex. But in a nutshell, they allow someone to profit immensely - staggeringly - if large numbers of subprime mortgages are not paid off and go into default.

The profit can be wildly out of proportion to the real amount of defaults, because speculators can push down the price of instruments tied to the subprime mortgages far beyond what the real rates of loss have been. As I said, the profits here can be beyond imagining. (In fact, they can be so large that one might well wonder if the whole subprime fiasco was not set up just to allow speculators to profit wildly on its collapse...)

These Credit Default Swaps have been written (as insurance is written) as private contracts. There is nil government regulation of them. Who writes these policies? Banks. Investment banks. Insurance companies. They now owe the buyers of these Credit Default Swaps on junk mortgage debt trillions of dollars. It is this liability that is the bottomless pit of liability for the financial institutions of America."

There are as much as $60 trillion (with a T) at stake in the totally unregulated CDS market - and those "bets" have to be paid by somebody, and nobody realy knows how many of those bets have become due.

The point is, we are deep in uncharted territory. Our economy stopped being about productivity, and has become "virtual" - based on financial manipulations nobody really understands.

Ben Stein ends with this....

"As I said, the pit of loss is bottomless. Warren Buffett, the smartest man of all time in the world of finance, has called financial derivatives - of which Credit Default Swaps are a prime example - "weapons of financial mass destruction." And so they are. As with the hydrogen bomb, no one thought they would ever be used to end the world. But unless someone figures a way out - and maybe the new RTC is and maybe it isn't - we are in real peril. This should never have happened. Now that it did happen, should the taxpayer pay to make the billionaire speculators whole on their bets? What the heck is to be done?"

Jim
2008-09-26, 08:16 PM
It is fun to look back, isn't it? :)
It was only back in March but good enough.
http://www.greenguysboard.com/board/showthread.php?t=38960

docholly
2008-09-26, 08:24 PM
Our economy stopped being about productivity, and has become "virtual" That's a huge part of the problem. No new manufacturing.. and the "new" business is shuffling $$ back and forth in a virtual world.

Whatever the outcome is, it's going to be long and messy and whoever gets in office in January is going to have to be less self-serving that those currently in office.

The whole thing is making me writhe in fetal position several times per day.

elKabong
2008-09-27, 12:38 AM
Unfortunately bailing out Wall Street is something we're going to have to do even though we'll have to do it while holding our noses because of the bullshit smell.

If banks don't grant credit due to fear of losses then business' will collapse, which causes the economy and the stock market to collapse, which causes unemployment and loss of wealth...

The normal reaction is to be angry and want to punish those that got us in this mess, but unfortunately punishing them will start the dominoes falling that will eventually hurt ourselves even more. Bailing them out is a tough pill to have to swallow, but it's got to be done, the details just have to be worked out.

Mr Spock
2008-09-28, 07:47 AM
What I find interesting is that experts talk of sub-prime losses running into trillions of $ (how much is a trillion anyway) , what is the market value of every house in the US? Surely not that much.

I find it pathetic that all the politicians on Capital Hill are wringing their hands agonising over poor taxpayers and protecting them form greedy bankers, isn't it these taxpayers who borrowed above their capacity to pay and have now caused this |crazy|

Instead of a banking bailout I propose a porn solution - all sluts working for i-banks must be seconded to the porn industry and suck cock until the economy improves |jester|

elKabong
2008-09-28, 11:09 PM
Instead of a banking bailout I propose a porn solution - all sluts working for i-banks must be seconded to the porn industry and suck cock until the economy improves |jester|

I'll vote for that plan... |thumb

Useless
2008-09-28, 11:35 PM
I find it pathetic that all the politicians on Capital Hill are wringing their hands agonising over poor taxpayers and protecting them form greedy bankers, isn't it these taxpayers who borrowed above their capacity to pay and have now caused this |crazy|Oddly enough, no.

Second, according to what I hear from my betters in the world of finance, the most serious problems are not with the bundles of subprime mortgages themselves — a large but not lethal quantum as far as I can tell — but with derivatives contracts tied to subprime and other dicey debt.
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/09/28/business/28every.html?scp=3&sq=ben%20stein&st=cse

But even if this crisis was the fault of a few hundred thousand foreclosures, would you blame the folly of the homeowners or the outright idiotic practices of the banks that would risk destroying themselves by knowingly giving those people the loans which they could so obviously not afford?

Also, our government is NOT "wringing their hands agonizing over poor taxpayers and protecting them from greedy bankers." They are working to keep the "greedy bankers" in business by using the money of the "poor taxpayers."

Bobc01
2008-09-29, 08:00 AM
I'd blame the banks and large performance bonuses paid by selling loans.
It's the bank and bankers fault and the US treasury for not keeping an eye on it, just as it is here with the Bank of England not having the power to cap the level of debt.

Just imagine, some of that $700 billion will be paid in large salaries to the arseholes that caused all this at your expense.
The same kind of bailouts are happening here with Bradford & Bingley and Northern Rock.
The Conservatives want bankers to be responsible for their own fuckups which is what should of happened long ago....

http://uk.news.yahoo.com/rtrs/20080929/tuk-uk-britain-conservatives-osborne-fa6b408.html

Ramster
2008-09-29, 11:11 AM
Starting to hit worldwide now more than people may think :(

"In Europe, Belgian-Dutch banking and insurance group Fortis sealed a multinational bailout over the weekend, while the British government on Monday announced it would nationalise troubled mortgage lender Bradford & Bingley.

Sentiment was also hit after German authorities provided 35 billion euros (50 billion dollars) in guarantees for an emergency credit line by a consortium of private banks to German bank Hypo Real Estate.

A fourth European bank, Franco-Belgian group Dexia, could also be on the verge of a state rescue deal after the group saw almost one quarter of its stock market value wiped out on liquidity concerns.

In another sign of banking woes, Denmark's Roskilde Bank said it had been sold to Nordic bank Nordea and two regional Danish lenders, Arbejdernes Landsbank and Spar Nord Bank.

Global central banks on Monday pumped extra cash into the financial system as part of continued efforts to keep credit flowing."

Mr. Blue
2008-09-29, 11:11 AM
There has to be a market correction at some point. It's simply inevitible. This bailout only postpones and shifts the effects of that correction. Sooner of later the price has to be paid. Until then it's all just playing games with numbers.

That's basically the gist of it. I tend to believe that delaying the inevitable will just worsen the situation...so I'm kind of on the fence regarding this bailout. Also whenever politicians say we must do something, it generally makes me question it even more.

RedCherry
2008-09-29, 11:30 AM
The crisis occurred (to greatly oversimplify) because the financial system allowed entities to place bets on whether or not those mortgages would ever be paid. You didn't have to own a mortgage to make the bets. These bets, called Credit Default Swaps, are complex. But in a nutshell, they allow someone to profit immensely - staggeringly - if large numbers of sub prime mortgages are not paid off and go into default.

The profit can be wildly out of proportion to the real amount of defaults, because speculators can push down the price of instruments tied to the subprime mortgages far beyond what the real rates of loss have been. As I said, the profits here can be beyond imagining. (In fact, they can be so large that one might well wonder if the whole subprime fiasco was not set up just to allow speculators to profit wildly on its collapse...)


I just see a bunch of people standing around a craps table that has 2000x odds betting on the no pass line when someone is rolling loaded dice.

All I want in this is a free-up of the credit market. I'm afraid if banks / businesses / joe blow's ability to get credit dries up, we are going to have an economic slowdown that is hideous in this country.

Ok, maybe it is a market correction and should be allowed to happen, but I think if sub prime speculation had been regulated, the market would have corrected over time, and not hit us all at once like it is now with the banks failing.

I don't know enough about all this to know what the best plan is, but I hope whatever they do, they leave the "insurance" aspect in this plan so that within 5 years if the companies bailed have made money, the taxpayer gets a slice of that profit.

T Pat
2008-09-29, 02:48 PM
It looks like it isn't going to pass and the stock market is in free fall

Useless
2008-09-29, 02:54 PM
I would LOVE a detailed explanation about how this will truly effect the average American, from the financial gurus, if the bailout doesn't pass. I keep hearing threats of doom and gloom, but without any real clarification of what the doom really is.

At this very moment, I'm quite happy that I don't have any money.

EDIT: THE BILL HAS FAILED. ANARCHY!!!

Mr. Blue
2008-09-29, 03:10 PM
I would LOVE a detailed explanation about how this will truly effect the average American, from the financial gurus, if the bailout doesn't pass. I keep hearing threats of doom and gloom, but without any real clarification of what the doom really is.

At this very moment, I'm quite happy that I don't have any money.

EDIT: THE BILL HAS FAILED. ANARCHY!!!

That's the thing that bothers me most about it. They keep making it like if it doesn't pass, boom, America shuts down and we put up the Not Open for Business sign.

Useless
2008-09-29, 03:12 PM
That's the thing that bothers me most about it. They keep making it like if it doesn't pass, boom, America shuts down and we put up the Not Open for Business sign.
The only thing I've heard so far is that it would be really difficult to get a mortgage. Well, my mortgage is held by one of the strong banks that is actually buying the failing banks and I have no immediate plans to sell my home, so, well, yeah. It's all about the banks' ability/willingness to extend credit.

Jim
2008-09-29, 03:13 PM
And the world is taking a shit. No more credit.

Mr. Blue
2008-09-29, 03:26 PM
The only thing I've heard so far is that it would be really difficult to get a mortgage. Well, my mortgage is held by one of the strong banks that is actually buying the failing banks and I have no immediate plans to sell my home, so, well, yeah. It's all about the banks' ability/willingness to extend credit.

Also a good dose of American's getting scared and putting their money in their mattress...that's the basics.

Torn Rose
2008-09-29, 03:43 PM
"We didnt get it passed cause Nancy was a meanie weinie"

Torn Rose
2008-09-29, 03:46 PM
Maybe SuperMcBush will swoop in and save us all!

Cleo
2008-09-29, 03:50 PM
So does this mean that if these securities that the government was bailing out do default then trillions of dollars in Credit Default Swap contracts will become due?

T Pat
2008-09-29, 04:17 PM
So does this mean that if these securities that the government was bailing out do default then trillions of dollars in Credit Default Swap contracts will become due?
No, they just won't be worth the paper they are written on

I'm looking forward to Mad Money today, Cramer should be entertaining

Bush and McSame sure are influential, NOT |thumb

tickler
2008-09-29, 06:34 PM
The only thing I've heard so far is that it would be really difficult to get a mortgage. Well, my mortgage is held by one of the strong banks that is actually buying the failing banks and I have no immediate plans to sell my home, so, well, yeah. It's all about the banks' ability/willingness to extend credit.
Hmmm, a lot of companies use their line of credit to do payrolls, buy raw materials, etc.

elKabong
2008-09-30, 12:03 AM
While on this subject, what's everyone doing with their existing stocks?

I have a monthly allotment into a diversified trading account and I'm thinking about converting all my existing stocks into treasury bonds, and then continuing to invest from here forward as before.

My thinking is that I should protect what I already have, but still get in on the fire sale that's coming.

Any thoughts?

SirMoby
2008-09-30, 01:57 AM
"We didnt get it passed cause Nancy was a meanie weinie"
That hurts my feelings. I'm going to go cry in the corner.

SirMoby
2008-09-30, 02:00 AM
While on this subject, what's everyone doing with their existing stocks?
I'm embarrassed to say that I pulled everything over a year ago because knew crisis was coming but didn't know exactly where. I've put it in all in CDs and am now earning 5.35% to 5.75%.

I'm even more embarrassed to say that about 1/2 of it I recently moved to Wachovia.

I've been telling people since 2000 this crisis was coming but I just wasn't enough to know how to make a billion on it.

Maj. Stress
2008-09-30, 02:17 AM
I'm embarrassed to say that I pulled everything over a year ago because knew crisis was coming but didn't know exactly where. I've put it in all in CDs and am now earning 5.35% to 5.75%.

I'm even more embarrassed to say that about 1/2 of it I recently moved to Wachovia.

I've been telling people since 2000 this crisis was coming but I just wasn't enough to know how to make a billion on it.
I've been waiting for something to happen a long time too. Anytime you see people fresh out of school with no jobs getting home loans for a really nice house while automakers are laying off workers by the thousand, you know something bad is about to happen.

LD
2008-09-30, 02:26 AM
While on this subject, what's everyone doing with their existing stocks?

I have a monthly allotment into a diversified trading account and I'm thinking about converting all my existing stocks into treasury bonds, and then continuing to invest from here forward as before.

My thinking is that I should protect what I already have, but still get in on the fire sale that's coming.

Any thoughts?


A lot depends on your age, but that sounds like a good safe thing to do. Of course if value comes back in a few days, you'll miss out.

Torn Rose
2008-09-30, 03:04 AM
That hurts my feelings. I'm going to go cry in the corner.

There there.... there there...

SheepGuy
2008-09-30, 03:41 AM
I sold my house a year ago. I liked the place, and I miss it, but I'm pretty sure I did the right thing. Next summer I'm moving to a cheaper part of the country and if the madness continues I should be able to buy a nicer place there for a bargain.
I'm hoping the madness doesn't continue though, because I get paid in Ameribucks, and it's real good for me when they're worth more than Canuckbucks.

webpimp
2008-09-30, 09:58 AM
I too have been following this very closely and I believe that we really need to be worried about this credit freeze that is just going to get worse.

I predict that several sponsors will go under in 2009. The sponsors that are operating in the red will not be able to pay you on time, and some will close up shop without paying you the remaining earnings on your account. Some sponsors will get bought out by the big guys if they are lucky and you will keep getting paid.

I think this is the immediate problem for all of us, rather than the consumers not having credit cards to buy memberships. But make no mistake, porn sales will go down because people will be too busy looking for a job.

Honestly, I don't know enough about finance and economics to either support or oppose this bailout plan. But I've learned more about this crisis from reading this thread than I learned from all 9 of Bush's mini-addresses.

Useless
2008-09-30, 10:44 AM
I predict that several sponsors will go under in 2009. The sponsors that are operating in the red will not be able to pay you on time, and some will close up shop without paying you the remaining earnings on your account. Some sponsors will get bought out by the big guys if they are lucky and you will keep getting paid. That's the only point I agree with you on, but I you could have predicted that before this crisis.

I predict everything will be fine for the average American. Sure, if you purchased a home within a the last few years, you probably aren't going to want to sell it for several more years since its market value is about to drop, and your 401K's value means you won't be able to retire tomorrow, otherwise, I've seen no reason to believe that we need to start looking for soup kitchens.

LD
2008-09-30, 11:03 AM
That's the only point I agree with you on, but I you could have predicted that before this crisis.

I predict everything will be fine for the average American. Sure, if you purchased a home within a the last few years, you probably aren't going to want to sell it for several more years since its market value is about to drop, and your 401K's value means you won't be able to retire tomorrow, otherwise, I've seen no reason to believe that we need to start looking for soup kitchens.

I tend to agree BUT...if we continue the policies of deregulation, and if the middle class continues losing wealth while wealth concentrates at the top of the economic ladder, we're fucked. 2/3 of our economy runs on consumer spending, and when their wages cannot keep up with prices, the economy grinds to a halt. Conservatives like to remind us that it is the wealthy that creates jobs...I like to remind them that it is the non-wealthy that buys the shit they sell, and if nobody is buying, there's no economy.

webpimp
2008-10-01, 01:10 AM
I predict everything will be fine for the average American. Sure, if you purchased a home within a the last few years, you probably aren't going to want to sell it for several more years since its market value is about to drop, and your 401K's value means you won't be able to retire tomorrow, otherwise, I've seen no reason to believe that we need to start looking for soup kitchens.

I hope you are right about that, and deep down I hold that feeling that everything will be ok. But first we have to get through a recession and I hope it's not an ugly one.

I tend to agree BUT...if we continue the policies of deregulation, and if the middle class continues losing wealth while wealth concentrates at the top of the economic ladder, we're fucked. 2/3 of our economy runs on consumer spending, and when their wages cannot keep up with prices, the economy grinds to a halt. Conservatives like to remind us that it is the wealthy that creates jobs...I like to remind them that it is the non-wealthy that buys the shit they sell, and if nobody is buying, there's no economy.

Absolutely we live in a consumer-based economy, and I agree that if the middle-class goes down then the rest of the economy tanks with it. Globalization might help soften this fall, since there is a market for American products in other parts of the world. But it comes at a cost of losing tons of domestic jobs to cheap labor overseas.

When it works, it's a big circle jerk and everyone gets off. When it doesn't work, it's a downward death spiral.

ArtWilliams
2008-10-01, 01:36 PM
Consider this:

- (Big money center) banks often deposit money with each other.
- Good banks won't place their money with poorly performing banks for fear of risk.
- As a result, all inter-bank deposit activity suffers (liquidity).
- The amount of money then available to loan out to businesses and consumers (or available as lines of credit) decreases because only with a liability (deposit) or capital on their books can a bank finance an asset (loan).
- less loans means less economic activity means less jobs.
- if your loans can't be funded then watch for your credit card limits and lines of credit to be reduced. In extreme cases, watch for your loans to be called (paid down or repayment) -- even if you are current in your payments!

Also consider:

- Lehman Brothers was the largest commercial paper market issuer in the country.
- If companies can't easily issue commercial paper then they can't finance short-term inventories which means they have to lay people off.
- Yes, someone will take Lehman's place but that doesn't happen over night. (Remember they were put into bankruptcy and not bought out.)

The problem with the bailout:

- It rewards bad companies for doing bad things, however, there are few options available.
- Banks not funding each other can have a big domino effect.
- During the depression 2/3 of the banks in the U.S. went bankrupt. Imagine the carnage if that were to happen today? What would happen in your town if 2/3 of the banks were gone along with everyone's savings?
- Short of the Fed being allowed to fund the good banks and, thereby increase liquidity, I am not sure what else they can do. And that last option would involve setting up some sort of state bank which I am sure would not be popular with the House Republicans. Also, who decides "good"?
- Long and the short of it is that ARMS were a small problem but left too long and they became a big one.
- A component of fraud is also likely as some are saying that ARMS were packaged and sold as AAA mortgages.
- There will be considerable inflation of prices AND devaluation of the U.S. dollar whatever route is picked to solve this mess.

I don't know if that adds anything to the conversation but I thought I would add my 2 cents.

I would LOVE a detailed explanation about how this will truly effect the average American, from the financial gurus, if the bailout doesn't pass. I keep hearing threats of doom and gloom, but without any real clarification of what the doom really is.

At this very moment, I'm quite happy that I don't have any money.

EDIT: THE BILL HAS FAILED. ANARCHY!!!

Useless
2008-10-01, 01:44 PM
I'm rolling with the Cato Institute. Let the market work itself out.

One of the commentators on CNBC keeps saying that this will hurt the man on Main St. in the short term if there is no bailout. How? Fewer toys on the shelves during Christmas? More difficult to get a new car loan? Idiots who shouldn't be getting home loans won't? 401K values decrease until the market comes back up (and it will)? Fucking fear mongers.

Screw that. I want Sodom and Gomorrah, and I want it now!

ArtWilliams
2008-10-01, 02:10 PM
That will work but is likely to be much more harsh in the short-term.

I'm rolling with the Cato Institute. Let the market work itself out.

One of the commentators on CNBC keeps saying that this will hurt the man on Main St. in the short term if there is no bailout. How? Fewer toys on the shelves during Christmas? More difficult to get a new car loan? Idiots who shouldn't be getting home loans won't? 401K values decrease until the market comes back up (and it will)? Fucking fear mongers.

Screw that. I want Sodom and Gomorrah, and I want it now!

Useless
2008-10-01, 02:16 PM
That will work but is likely to be much more harsh in the short-term.I don't mind. :)

Being that there is nothing even similar to a guarantee if the bailout goes through, I don't see it as a risk worth taking. Every single expert, when told something similar to, "this bailout is just as likely not do anything," completely agrees with the statement. That's scary.

I vote: chaos.

LD
2008-10-01, 02:35 PM
Everything eventualy works itself out, even the fall of The Roman Empire. It's just the misery we go through during the transition....sorta like waiting for the Barbarians to settle down and become Europe. Not something I would anticipate with glee.

But fuck it, bring it on...

papagmp
2008-10-01, 03:12 PM
I really wanted to add something useful here - but I think I need to shit..........

Shit in - shit out!

ArtWilliams
2008-10-01, 03:32 PM
Yes. Essentially, the mortgage (which has been changed into a security) is swapped (with a paper contract). If the mortgage is defaulted then the holder of the swap contract would enforce it on the third party holding it.

So does this mean that if these securities that the government was bailing out do default then trillions of dollars in Credit Default Swap contracts will become due?

papagmp
2008-10-01, 03:38 PM
OK - so I only slept three hours last night and my brian cells are all dead - but this is what I do know:

1. Almost half of the scheduled rebills this month were returned with this message: "Rebill Failed Notice"

2. I've received three emails like this one in the last 7 days: "Hi my name is Ruth and I just wanted to see what ur company is all about. I am currently unemployed and all the bills are due and I'm kinda at my whits-end and need cash quick. So if you could email me back w some details about how u work I'd appreciate it greatly or you can call : 719-555-5555 Thanx for ur time!! PEACE&LOVE"

Oh - and I'm closing the tipi shop as of Friday so my once-stable income of just over $200K has dwindled to a few memberships a month. With any luck, I'll be able to continue to pay the mortgage on this over-priced $152,000.00 home - which was very modest at the time I bought it and feels like a fucking boat anchor right now.

But look on the bright side - the cost of a good blowjob is falling as more and more people are driven to their knees.

ArtWilliams
2008-10-01, 04:01 PM
The whole swap market can be used as either a bet or a hedge (to reduce risk). Here is an example:

Bank A has one loan and one deposit to simplify things. The loan (asset) matures in 5 years. The deposit (liability) matures in 1 year. Bank A would like to better match the two so it can lock in its spread (income from loan - amount paid to depositor). It goes out to the swap market and finds another Bank (Bank B). Bank B also has one loan and one deposit to simplify things. The loan (asset) matures in 2 years. The deposit (liability) matures in 5 years. The two banks create a contract on paper to swap their deposits. This is an off balance sheet or contingent item with only the net difference ever being paid out. The customers holding the deposits never know and get their money from the Banks where they deposited their money.

As a result of the swap, Bank A has achieved the goal of matching the terms of its assets and liabilities and locked in its spread. The act of doing this, however, creates counterparty risk because the swap party (Bank B) has to follow through on his contract (with Bank A). Swaps can be used for many, many types of transactions (interest rates, foreign exchange, lengths of contracts, etc.). They are not risky unless they are done naked (also called unhedged).

The real fear here is, with trillions of dollars of contingent liabilities, there is no way of knowing what will happen if large sums of them default.


People said that?

Bwah-hah-hah-hah-choke-sputter-cough.

But you're right, thats a whole nuther discussion.

---

I thought what Ben Stein said about credit default swaps being the real problem, the HUGE problem hidden behind the mortgage bailout, is relevant.

http://finance.yahoo.com/expert/article/yourlife/109609

"Here s one big part of the answer. First, the alert reader will notice that Ben Stein said many times that the amount of money at risk in the subprime meltdown was just not enough to sink an economy of this size. And I was right...to a point. The amount of subprime that defaulted was at most - after recovery in liquidation - about $250 billion. A huge sum but not enough to torpedo the US economy.

The crisis occurred (to greatly oversimplify) because the financial system allowed entities to place bets on whether or not those mortgages would ever be paid. You didn't have to own a mortgage to make the bets. These bets, called Credit Default Swaps, are complex. But in a nutshell, they allow someone to profit immensely - staggeringly - if large numbers of subprime mortgages are not paid off and go into default.

The profit can be wildly out of proportion to the real amount of defaults, because speculators can push down the price of instruments tied to the subprime mortgages far beyond what the real rates of loss have been. As I said, the profits here can be beyond imagining. (In fact, they can be so large that one might well wonder if the whole subprime fiasco was not set up just to allow speculators to profit wildly on its collapse...)

These Credit Default Swaps have been written (as insurance is written) as private contracts. There is nil government regulation of them. Who writes these policies? Banks. Investment banks. Insurance companies. They now owe the buyers of these Credit Default Swaps on junk mortgage debt trillions of dollars. It is this liability that is the bottomless pit of liability for the financial institutions of America."

There are as much as $60 trillion (with a T) at stake in the totally unregulated CDS market - and those "bets" have to be paid by somebody, and nobody realy knows how many of those bets have become due.

The point is, we are deep in uncharted territory. Our economy stopped being about productivity, and has become "virtual" - based on financial manipulations nobody really understands.

Ben Stein ends with this....

"As I said, the pit of loss is bottomless. Warren Buffett, the smartest man of all time in the world of finance, has called financial derivatives - of which Credit Default Swaps are a prime example - "weapons of financial mass destruction." And so they are. As with the hydrogen bomb, no one thought they would ever be used to end the world. But unless someone figures a way out - and maybe the new RTC is and maybe it isn't - we are in real peril. This should never have happened. Now that it did happen, should the taxpayer pay to make the billionaire speculators whole on their bets? What the heck is to be done?"

Megan Essog
2008-10-01, 05:07 PM
I wish someone would bail me out ;)
No one comes to my aid when I'm broke!

Jim
2008-10-01, 07:14 PM
I wish someone would bail me out ;)
No one comes to my aid when I'm broke!

Someone probably would if you being broke caused millions of others to be broke :)

Something has to be done to release credit again. I have spoken to a few friends that own businesses and they are hurting more than any of us. One, a car dealer, can't seem to get anyone a loan. Another, the owner of a large office furniture manufacturer, could not get this weeks payroll and...their building loan went from 1.3% to over 3 percent. The increase of the loan is about $8k/week.

SirMoby
2008-10-02, 12:18 AM
Someone probably would if you being broke caused millions of others to be broke :)

Something has to be done to release credit again. I have spoken to a few friends that own businesses and they are hurting more than any of us. One, a car dealer, can't seem to get anyone a loan. Another, the owner of a large office furniture manufacturer, could not get this weeks payroll and...their building loan went from 1.3% to over 3 percent. The increase of the loan is about $8k/week.

OK, so let's start a tax payer run bank that has $700 Billion in loans and it gets distributed evenly to communities based on census data.

Oh yeah, the people that get to run it are the people in the local communities. Some will be fucking crooks and some won't but none of them will have enough money for Wall Street to make them crooked.

webpimp
2008-10-02, 04:22 PM
The money will go to the largest financial firms in the world. Watch them all swarm to DC looking for a handout: http://www.nytimes.com/2008/09/22/business/22lobby.html?_r=1&ref=todayspaper&oref=slogin

Bobc01
2008-10-02, 05:01 PM
They'll be like vultures now that money has been approved.

They'll make their usual large salaries and continue to fuck up in ways that the entire $700 billion might aswell of been flushed down the shitter.