PDA

View Full Version : Fuck those instant hot water heaters


Jim
2006-03-26, 11:06 AM
A few months ago, I spent something like $800 on an Electric Instant Hot Water Heater that was rated to handle our entire house. After Having the overheat reset buttons pop no less than twice/week, I finally figured out that I had to both turn down the temperature and reduce the pressure for it to work. So, the water was not as hot as it should be and the pressure of the hot water was about half of the cold.

Something must have told me when I installed it to keep the perfectly good old fashioned 40 gallon gas watter heater because there it sat...right next to the new one. I finally broke down and gave up on the instant hot and hooked up the gas heater and while taking a shower, I felt like a new man.

With the Electric heater taking 3 60 amp breakers to run, I really don't think I was saving that much money anyway. From now on, if it ain't broke, I won't fix it :)

Surfn
2006-03-26, 11:09 AM
The reduced stress may help to further alleviate your headaches too :)

Greenguy
2006-03-26, 11:09 AM
We were gonna get one of those after seeing it down at CES (Hi Spud |waves|) but we decided to go a different root & I'm glad we did. We're getting some system that reuses the heat form the baseboard heating system in the house to heat the water (and it runs by itself like a normal hot water tank when the heating system is off)

dareutwo
2006-03-26, 11:15 AM
Jim -
Sounds like the infloor electric heat we tried here at the cabin when we remodeled. 2 weeks after we turned in on, it started blowing breakers. It's covered in 4 inches of concrete and carpeting. We simply ended up disconnecting the whole thing and installed baseboard electric around the lower level. With those, if 1 goes out, just switch it for 30 bucks.

Simon
2006-03-26, 11:19 AM
GG - I've heard good things about those systems that use the baseboard heat.

Jim - Almost everyone down here had to replace their water heaters after Wilma's storm surge (along with most other major applicances). I've heard folks at the local bars and restaurants having major bitch sessions about having tried those new "instant" heaters and getting the same results you did.

MrYum
2006-03-26, 11:31 AM
Thanks for the heads up Jim |thumb

I had it in my head to try one of those when my current w/h gives up. Sounds like I'll be staying with the ol tried and true method when the time comes.

juggernaut
2006-03-27, 06:09 PM
Thanks jim. I looking at a house now that has electric heat and it had me concerned as I dont want a billion dolar heating bill. But the house also has a gas stove and dryer so I need to find out what it would cost to convert the house to gas heat. There is central AC so I'm hopping not to much of a headache. Then maybe I can have a house with my own dam yard.

Jim
2006-03-28, 07:34 AM
We were gonna get one of those after seeing it down at CES (Hi Spud |waves|) but we decided to go a different root & I'm glad we did. We're getting some system that reuses the heat form the baseboard heating system in the house to heat the water (and it runs by itself like a normal hot water tank when the heating system is off)
That is the exact system we had in the other house. It's really a big tank with a coil hooked up to your boiler, right? I miss that, a lot. You have the power of your boiler for domestic hot water so you never run out. The only strange thing is hearing the boiler fire up in the middle of summer. But, that is by far the most efficient way to heat domestic water. By the way, the boiler doesn't run much. We used oil...and in the winter, we used about 250 gallons every 2 weeks. We went the entire summer on 1 tank (250 Gallons) for our hot water.

Jim
2006-03-28, 07:37 AM
Anyone that heats their home with hot water, should use the system Greenie is using. Any energy person will tell you it is the most effecient.

terry
2006-03-28, 08:47 AM
I agree there.. thanks for the heads up. I know I'll have to change my hot water tank soon, so I better shop around and ask a lot of questions ;)

SirMoby
2006-03-28, 10:17 AM
We were gonna get one of those after seeing it down at CES (Hi Spud |waves|) but we decided to go a different root & I'm glad we did. We're getting some system that reuses the heat form the baseboard heating system in the house to heat the water (and it runs by itself like a normal hot water tank when the heating system is off)
Haven't they been using those in Europe for decades? At least heating floors using hot water.

Simon
2006-03-28, 11:49 AM
Haven't they been using those in Europe for decades? At least heating floors using hot water.
Actually there's been a system somewhat like that in use for quite a while. One of the earliest used hot air, but the same basic idea.

http://www.romans-in-britain.org.uk/inv_central_heating.htm

My guess is even back then, there were posts on the wall of the baths about how one hypocaust system or another was better. :D

PR_Tom
2006-03-28, 05:54 PM
I would like one of those on-demand gas fired jobbers though. And get one thats way over rated too to be on the safe side. There are days when the ONLY hot water used in this house is a 10 minute shower.. 23 hours and 50 minutes it's just sitting there heating up the tank for no reason.

Its like leaving your car running in the driveway all day for a short trip to the store :)

I'd get one rated for 2 appliances, and then I'd only ever use 1, just like now.

juggernaut
2006-03-28, 11:46 PM
GG can you give more input to the system you are using? Name or link and $$. The houses I'm looking at here, alot of them are using electric water heaters. Dam eletric bill is high enough here.