View Full Version : Watched "Walmart, The Cost of Low Prices"
Seriously, if you have a relative that works at walmart, watch this movie. If you shop at walmart, watch this movie.
Berkley did a study just for California and it costs taxpayers over $83million in health care because of walmart. In the US as a whole...well over a $Billion.
RedCherry
2006-02-15, 12:46 PM
Wow, why? Since I live in a town where WalMart is our only shopping option for most items, unless you want to make a 120 mile round trip into Vegas, I shop alot there.
Part of it is this...You can get insurance through Walmart but...you have to pay the whole share. People that work at Walmart can't afford to have medical insurance, live in public housing and work overtime without pay. 31 states have sued and won for them not paying overtime. During hurricane Katrina, Walmart donated $5,006,000.00 $5 million was donated by the employees, $6000 was donated by the Waltons who are all consistently in the top 10 richest people in the US. The Walton family donates .001% of their yearly income. Conversely, Bill Gates donates 53% of his yearly income to charities.
Then you go to China where almost everything at Walmart is made. They are paid $3/day and are expected to work 18 hours/day. They don't have to live in the Walmart dorm but if they chose not to, they still have to pay the rent. If they are being punished for not working hard enough, they must work a month without pay.
There have been several Walmart stores that have voted for a union. Those stores were promptly closed down. Not to mention that when a Walmart comes into a town, mom and pop stores last about a year.
If the Waltons gave up 10% of their income, every Walmart employee could not only get free health insurance but also get a livable wage.
The Waltons are the Getty's of this century. If George W didn't call the CEO the same pet name his wife called him, they would have been broken up already.
It just goes on and on and on...
Watch the movie and you will never shop there again. A lot of hidden cameras and nothing like a Moore documentary. All facts that can easily be proven.
Oh yeah...one more thing called a peasant policy. While new employees sign all the papers to work there, they sign a peasant policy. This is a life insurance policy that goes to Walmart when the employee dies. So, after a few more years, they will be making money just from people working there and dying one day.
Oh yeah....those cameras you see in the parking lots. They are not for shopper's protection...they are looking for unions. Over 20,000 people were raped, beaten or just stolen from last year alone in a Walmart parking lot.
RedCherry
2006-02-15, 02:02 PM
OMG I had no idea. The sad thing is, it is one of the biggest employers, if not the biggest in my town.
Since Nevada is a "right to work state" we have crappy wages in most every sector, with horrible health insurance benefits. Before I moved to NV, I lived all my adult life in Hawaii, and I thought every state was like them... full paid medical benefits if you work over 20 hours a week, and you are entitled after the first month. And, employers must give you a choice. I got a rude wakeup call when I went to work for a casino and found out I had to work 6 months before I got health insurance, and then I had to pay about 1/2 the premium cost.
I have a better health insurance plan now being self insured then I had at any job I worked at in this state, which is a sad fact.
I'll have to watch out for the film. Is it just on TV, or could I find it at the video rental store?
It just came out not too long ago on DVD
RedCherry
2006-02-15, 03:32 PM
It just came out not too long ago on DVD
Thanks, I'll go look for it to rent. |thumb Doubt seriously I could buy it at WalMart, lol.
SirMoby
2006-02-15, 04:05 PM
But Jim, all the studies show that Walmart creates 100 jobs per new store. Just watch Fox News and they'll tell you that Walmart is the best thing to ever happen to America.
Of course most independant studies show a different reality.
RawAlex
2006-02-15, 04:06 PM
Jim, that movie is a well known one sided hatchet job. Nobody from Walmart was involved in the making of it, and the movie was majority financed through union groups and other "interested" organizations.
NBC’s “Today,” CNN’s “Showbiz” and “Lou Dobbs Tonight” all included Wal-Mart’s response to Greenwald’s documentary, saying there were three errors in three minutes in his trailer. None, however, told viewers what those errors were. Wal-Mart made a short video explaining those inaccuracies:
* Greenwald showed a hardware store and stated that Wal-Mart put it out of business. But the store closed before Wal-Mart opened, was sold to a new owner, and is now open and looking to expand.
* The trailer had an African-American woman stating, “He just bluntly told me there is no place for people like you in management.” What she meant by “people like you” was never specified, the viewer is left to guess, but assume it’s either racial or gender. In regard to race and sex, Wal-Mart is one of America’s most diverse companies. Black Enterprise magazine rated it as one of the “30 Best Companies for Diversity,” and more than 40 percent of Wal-Mart managers are women. “Time Magazine” ran a story on September 5 about the growing support that Wal-Mart has from “black America.”
* The trailer showed a man who said “if they don’t pay a living wage, they can’t come to Chicago.” Wal-Mart pays on average more than $4 an hour above minimum wage, and $1 higher than the “living wage” set by Chicago for city contracts.
That was the three minute trailer.
I like the Michael Moore mentality, I like the "hang them with their own words", but the movie itself starts with too much of a biased point of view to even self-evaluate the points being made to see if they are correct or not.
Blaming a company like Wal-mart for working conditions in China isn't a stretch, but it is a weak causal link. If all companies in China charged 10% more for their good, Wal-mart would likely pay that 10% more than they pay now. Labor is cheap and people work like dogs in China because they need the work and their government permits and encourages such working conditions. If the Chinese government enforced better working conditions, the prices would go up and Walmart would likely pay that higher price (and pass it on to consumers).
Go look around your house. Where you see a label marked "made in china" or "made in taiwan" you probably want to get rid of it, you supported slave labor (and got ripped off by a higher price retailer that made a larger profit than Wal-mart selling it to you).
Alex
Alex
I have 6 in laws that have either worked at Walmart or work there now. And they watched it and they all agreed, they were expected to work extra time for free, could not afford the insurance and since their last names are Gonzalez, they had to put up with racist comments.
Just one of those things i guess like the Michael Moore movies.
RawAlex
2006-02-15, 04:22 PM
Jim, yet none of them made formal complaints, they all accepted the jobs and the pay, and went along with it?
My feeling is that Wal-mart certainly pushes the limits (and often goes past them), and that their sheer size and influence in the US and world market makes them a good target.
I like Michael Moore (I have a couple of his books here, he is quite funny at times) but there is a point where he crosses from intent to inform and moves right over to intent to make people look bad even if they are not as bad as he wishes they were. He is a truly skilled film maker that has taught a whole generation of wanna-bees to make sarcastic movies that often don't portray the sides of the issue that would detract from their goal of belittling and mocking companies or individuals.
http://channels.netscape.com/news/story.jsp?id=2006021501190002352254&dt=20060215011900&w=RTR&coview=
There are all sides on this one - including some good old american bashing from Europe.
Alex
They really had no choice about working there. And 1 of my sister's in law was fired for what they said stealing. Although she never stole a thing. She wanted her overtime. The others...they are just morons :)
RedCherry
2006-02-15, 04:30 PM
I like Michael Moore (I have a couple of his books here
Alex
Me too, my brother went to school with him, nice to see someone from my home town make it big. :D
Now it is hard to know who is right on the is WalMart a good place to work or not. One thing I do plan on doing is when I go shopping next time, I'll talk to some of the workers there, I'm friends with almost everyone in the store. Ok, we have no malls to hang out, so everyone hangs out there to chat.
ecchi
2006-02-15, 04:35 PM
Not being American, and never having shopped in Walmart I cannot comment on the original argument. However "some good old American bashing from Europe" is a stupid and ignorant comment for two reasons:
1. Europe has plenty of stores with the same faults that this film claims for Walmart, I have even worked for a couple of them in the distant (but not distant enough) past. Any comments from Europe on this subject (if there are any) would be along the lines of "they are as bad as us". "American bashing" takes the form of "they are worse than us", and those that do it only pick on targets where those who defend America cannot say "you do it too".
2. All comments I have heard in the British media (Britain is part of Europe) have been from American commentators, or from people who are commenting on American commentators.
ecchi
2006-02-15, 04:38 PM
Re-reading my last post, and knowing how sensitive some members are here, can I point out that I said THE ARGUMENT is "is a stupid and ignorant" not that RawAlex was, before someone deliberately misreads my post.
RawAlex
2006-02-15, 04:39 PM
They really had no choice about working there. And 1 of my sister's in law was fired for what they said stealing. Although she never stole a thing. She wanted her overtime. The others...they are just morons :)
So they were taken a gunpoint to work? Perhaps the government set up a secret draft to enlist people to work at the stores. Maybe (as suggested in the Simpsons) they put devices on the workers to control their thoughts.
Nahh.
Ecchi, this movie didn't get played much in America, but it has found a welcoming audience in Europe that it didn't find here. There seems to be some sort of satisfaction in finding that "the best of America" could be the worst.
Alex
Has Walmart started the lawsuit against the maker of this movie yet? I mean, the Government could not sue Moore for his movie but Walmart has all the right in the world if the movie is nothing but slanderous tripe.
Check out their internal memo
http://www.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/business/26walmart.pdf
So they were taken a gunpoint to work? Perhaps the government set up a secret draft to enlist people to work at the stores. Maybe (as suggested in the Simpsons) they put devices on the workers to control their thoughts.
Nahh.
Ecchi, this movie didn't get played much in America, but it has found a welcoming audience in Europe that it didn't find here. There seems to be some sort of satisfaction in finding that "the best of America" could be the worst.
Alex
No, I guess since all but one retail store in this area went out of business when walmart opened, they could have tried to work there. Or, they could have just gone on welfare. I agree with you...they had choices.
Alex, are you some sort of secret Republican in disguise? :)
RawAlex
2006-02-15, 04:47 PM
Jim, question: Why did all the retail stores close? Because they could not compete against a company that offered low prices? Or would it more be that the customers chose to shop at the lower priced store?
You seem to want your higher priced job and quaint mainstreets, but as a whole americans have voted with their wallets and their feet (or cars). Pure capitalism without checks and balances mean that people often do things that are against what they "want" because it satisfies a baser need.
Walmart's fault or the nature of the system?
Alex
RawAlex
2006-02-15, 04:49 PM
Alex, are you some sort of secret Republican in disguise? :)
Nope, according to MikeAI, I am as liberal as they come, making Dean look like a bible thumper.
I just think that blaming Walmart for being successful is a weak way of shifting the blame from the very consumers that drive it.
Alex
I guess the smaller retail stores didn't have access to cheap Chinese labor.
I guess the smaller retail stores didn't have access to cheap Chinese labor.and were likely paying overtime and paying for health coverage and other benefits
fetish1
2006-02-15, 04:58 PM
I suppose too it depends on the individual managers of each location to a degree. My friends little sister works at Wally World while going to college, and she gets overtime frequently (paid that is). I also have to ask if that movie discussed the tuition reimbursement program they offer to college students that are employed there? Sounds like they mentioned a lot of bad, and none of the upsides of that employer.
RawAlex
2006-02-15, 04:59 PM
Jim, honestly, is it Wal-mart's fault that they did better? It is their fault that they have developed a retail strategy that is most attractive to the buyers?
Is there any reasons why they should be punished for being the best?
Alex
ecchi
2006-02-15, 05:03 PM
Ecchi, this movie didn't get played much in America, but it has found a welcoming audience in Europe that it didn't find here. There seems to be some sort of satisfaction in finding that "the best of America" could be the worst.
I got this deal with my local multiplex, I pay a monthly subscription rather than an individual "per visit" price, so I tend to go to the cinema several times a week. I also get several film magazines, and I am a member of "The British Film Institute". But I had never heard about this movie until Jim mentioned it. You are probably right in that it is popular in art houses aimed at students and left over hippies, but very wrong in saying "it has found a welcoming audience in Europe". If it is showing here, it is a minor movie playing in a few specialist cinemas. The last major "US bashing" movie to be a big hit over here was Team America, which throws the shit at all sides. It was also hilarious if you can stand the shit slinging (and whichever side you are on, you are going to be offended, it sort of says that the war in Iraq is wrong, and everyone who disagrees with it is also wrong, and that Michael Moore is right, but everyone who agrees with Michael Moore is an asshole)
Actually the opinion in Britain on Walmart tends to be less about human rights and more about the fact that Walmart is crippling the American balance of payments with it's excessive reliance on imports, and when the American economy eventually collapses and you go 1930's again, Walmart will be one of the main causes.
(And the fact that most of Europe sees America's imminent economical collapse as a "when" rather than an "if" is because the majority of Americans are believed (by Europeans) to have a "So Walmart do this, but what can you do? They are cheaper" attitude.)
The internal memo I posted is 27 pages long so I know you didn't read it Alex.
I also notice that you skipped the question about a lawsuit.
Here is a quick article...
Don't trust the website, just trust where the article came from...
http://www.commondreams.org/headlines05/0210-13.htm
ecchi
2006-02-15, 05:06 PM
Sorry, got a bit confused, is this film one of Michael Moore's, or are you saying it is like his movies?
Sorry, got a bit confused, is this film one of Michael Moore's, or are you saying it is like his movies?
Really, neither...
ecchi
2006-02-15, 05:14 PM
Thanks
RawAlex
2006-02-15, 05:15 PM
Jim, 27 page internal memos aren't something I want to spend a whole bunch of time reading without reason. You may want to bring one or two of the best points here and start discussion on them.
As for the lawsuit, considering that there would be little upside for Walmart to fight such a lawsuit (get a mutlibillion dollar settlement from a filmmaker that doesn't have 2 cents to his name). In all reality, it would likely give this guy a forum in which he could bring more disgruntled employees into the public light to diss the company.
You didn't notice that he only interviewed disgruntled employees, and none of the "gruntled" ones? If the personal officer was so upset about Walmart, why was he there 17 years?
ecchi, this is a "moore like" movie. I suspect this guy spent a little too much time watching "Roger & me".
As for the "welcome audience", it isn't a question of your local cineplex playing the movie, but that some film festivals and movie review houses have made a big deal over it. These are the people who in influence the public's perception of a film as worthy or not worthy.
Alex
Jim, 27 page internal memos aren't something I want to spend a whole bunch of time reading without reason. You may want to bring one or two of the best points here and start discussion on them.
As for the lawsuit, considering that there would be little upside for Walmart to fight such a lawsuit (get a mutlibillion dollar settlement from a filmmaker that doesn't have 2 cents to his name). In all reality, it would likely give this guy a forum in which he could bring more disgruntled employees into the public light to diss the company.
First, the memo is how their crappy practices are being brought to the light of day and a way to change their practices even thought it would be expensive.
Second...
Are you kidding me about the lawsuit. If someone is spreading slander about one of the biggest corporations in the world, a lawsuit would clear the air. It would prove that nothing said in that movie was true. Of course, it's not slander if it's true.
Oh, the movie did have plenty of employees that seemed ok getting screwed. They filmed someone with shopping carts in the walmart parking lot saying "that seems about right" when asked about low wages and the inability to live on what he makes without help from welfare.
I've got to get going so...take your time, think about the non-lawsuit, breeze the memo and I will talk to you tomorrow.
ecchi
2006-02-15, 05:41 PM
As for the "welcome audience", it isn't a question of your local cineplex playing the movie, but that some film festivals and movie review houses have made a big deal over it. These are the people who in influence the public's perception of a film as worthy or not worthy.
No as a general rule film festivals tend to get little publicity outside a small anorak type grouping (again mostly students and hippies). If I were bothered I could probably find as many French people who had seen a movie that championed America and had convinced them that America was great, but that would not show that France in general had learnt to like America. If you want to influence people over here it's got to either be a blockbuster movie (like Team America) or a prime time TV show.
The fact is that Europe has become a bit "bored" with the USA, and although a lot of people tend to look down on America (it tends to be thought of as being a slightly "backward" country full of people who are a little "less bright" than the rest of the world, and also a bit of a "bully"), but that has nothing to do with this film, it has been the European view of America for decades. Apart from Team America, which was successful because of the popularity of South Park, and the fact that it was a very funny film in it's own right, "America Bashing" movies tend to just get watched by the minority who think it is "hip" and ignored by the majority of the public.
biftek
2006-02-15, 10:27 PM
lets face it , working in chain stores like that , you don't have to be an einstein to work in those stores , heck they could train monkeys do those jobs , want a higher paying job , get better education
The long and short of it is that you will never become wealthy by working hard and saving. You become wealthy by exploiting others, and that's all there is too it.
docholly
2006-02-15, 10:54 PM
Watch the movie and you will never shop there again. A lot of hidden cameras and nothing like a Moore documentary. All facts that can easily be proven.
I haven't shopped at Walmart in probably at least 6 - 8 years. Not that i think Target or KMart are so much better but i do feel i am doing my part to NOT contribute to the Wally-world mentality.
Virginia.. come shopping in Vegas, we'll do lunch!!! :D
RedCherry
2006-02-15, 11:06 PM
...i do feel i am doing my part to NOT contribute to the Wally-world mentality.
Virginia.. come shopping in Vegas, we'll do lunch!!! :D
Sounds like a plan! I never shopped at WalMart much until I moved out here, although anything I'm not in a hurry for I tend to shop online and get as much as possible, or wait for a trip into Vegas. :)
emmanuelle
2006-02-16, 02:58 PM
Oh yeah...one more thing called a peasant policy. While new employees sign all the papers to work there, they sign a peasant policy. This is a life insurance policy that goes to Walmart when the employee dies. So, after a few more years, they will be making money just from people working there and dying one day.
This was an issue brought up in one of Moore's books. Many companies do this apparently, not only Walmart.
Like most works of 'non-fiction', one should view with objectivity, as the producers likely did not. Everyone is entitled to an opinion, but today's society seems to prefer the more salacious view for entertainment purposes.
btw- Walmart is China's EIGHTH largest trading partner. China will do whatever is necessary to maintain that relationship. I wonder if there is an opportunity in this to encourage them to improve their human rights record?
RawAlex
2006-02-16, 03:21 PM
Emma, you will certainly remember this: In a smaller city in Quebec, they were able to get a union organized for the Walmart workers. This would be the first unionized Walmart in the world. Once the union put forth it's contract proposal, Walmart announced that the store would be closed.
On the surface, it looks like "anti-union action". But in reality Walmart cannot keep the lowest prices and pay higher wages and deal with restrictive work rules. It is the nature of the game - low prices come from somewhere, Walmart is making a profit, so I would have to guess that it comes from lower costs, great automation, and keeping employee salaries and benefits in line with being a discount retailer.
Trying to turn a job as a cashier or a shelf stocker into a "house, two cars, 2.3 kids, cat dog, white picket fence" is just not going to happen. If being a Walmart greeter is your idea of a career, then you need to adjust your lifestyle expectations as a result. Sorry, but it just doesn't make sense.
"peasant policies" are a fairly common situation, created by preferential tax laws for certain types of investments. It isn't a nice thing to look at from a personal stand point (you are worth more to your company dead than alive is the common phrasing, not really true), but it is something that is created by the law, and which could be eliminated by simple changes to the tax laws. Congress has not seen fit to fix this, so therefore it must be legal and acceptable.
I think it could be looked at as an interesting way for a company to recoup the investment made in training an employee.
Alex
fetish1
2006-02-16, 03:44 PM
Trying to turn a job as a cashier or a shelf stocker into a "house, two cars, 2.3 kids, cat dog, white picket fence" is just not going to happen. If being a Walmart greeter is your idea of a career, then you need to adjust your lifestyle expectations as a result. Sorry, but it just doesn't make sense.
I have to second this, and from the looks of things at our local Wallmart, 85% of the employee pool (non-managerial) is made up of college students and seniors who are looking for some part time hours to supplement their social security benefits (and or retirement income from past jobs).
Lenny
2006-02-21, 03:00 AM
I bought this DVD when it came out as well. It didn't tell me alot I didn't already know but it certainly reinforced the way I already felt about the company.
At first my wife and I were going to boycott Wal-Mart.....then I did some research trying to figure out where the "labor friendly" place to shop was.
Turns out all the "big box" retailers are engaging in the same sort of practices, in an effort to keep up with the Waltons.
So really we don't have much of a choice when it comes to where to shop. We live in a "right to work" state so there are no grocery chains or general merchandisers with union employees here.
While I am appalled at the way the Wal Marts of the world do business, about all I can do about it is make a contribution to the AFL CIO and vote Democrat. *shrugs shoulders*
Lenny
2006-02-21, 03:07 AM
lets face it , working in chain stores like that , you don't have to be an einstein to work in those stores , heck they could train monkeys do those jobs , want a higher paying job , get better education
.
I could say the same thing about getting a job in a GM plant in Detroit. Most of those guys have just a high school education, the rest of the training is provided by the company.
They make $27 an hour.
It doesn't take alot of brains to be a flight attendant or a baggage handler either but those people get paid well because they have the right to bargain collectively for their wages and benefits.
If Wal-Mart is allowed to use its buying power to get lower prices from suppliers then why can't Wal-Mart's workers use their "collective labor power" to get better wages and benefits?
Seems like a double standard to me.
biftek
2006-02-21, 04:38 AM
well bettter education can mean many things , could mean to read the fine print , could mean to check the jobsearch alot more often , could mean networking with others to find better positions, can also mean to know their rights , education is no just grades on a piece of paper
the workers can use there collective labor power , all they need to do is form together and call a mass strike , at the end of the day the workers have the power to run the company , without them the store would turn to shit , sure they can fire the lot of them but that takes time and money
if the workers can hold off long enough with no source of income they can change things
walmart and the like use the same tactic when they are bargaining better deals , they walk in with there power and money saying we want this at X price or we will take our business elsewhere( ok might be more to it then take ,but you get the idea)
most established unions are crap anyway
i don't know abou others but with my jobs
I have always had the right to pick and choose where, when and for how much I work.
I make the decision at interview time whether or not I work for someone.
At no stage am I over a barrel to take the job, but if I do I'd better be prepared to accept the wages and conditions on offer or go elsewhere.
If the potential employer can't see the value I possess and be prepered to pay for it, then they're not worth working for - simply walk away.
RawAlex
2006-02-21, 11:14 AM
Lenny, airlines and car companies are interesting choices. In both cases, they are industries where the existing "big guys" are all suffering because of thing they have given during past labor negotiations.
In GM's case, legacy labor costs (the cost of retiree benefits) are costing the company huge amounts of money each year, which would be the difference between profit and loss in most cases.
In airline cases, many, many of those companies have gone bankrupt in the US over the last 10 years, and the usual solution is MASSIVE rollbacks in employee wages and benefits.
If they put those costs into tickets or cars, we would be paying 30% to 50% more.
If every Walmart employee wanted to make stocking shelves into a family supporting career, I would suspect that prices at the store would go up rather dramatically (because not only would wages go up, but because shop rules would probably double the amount of staff required to run the stores).
Alex
Lenny
2006-02-21, 03:45 PM
Lenny, airlines and car companies are interesting choices. In both cases, they are industries where the existing "big guys" are all suffering because of thing they have given during past labor negotiations.
I disagree totally.
The reason GM is losing money is because of bad management. They put too much faith into gas guzzling SUV's and when oil prices spiked they were screwed. Same thing with Ford.
The car companies that are flourishing right now are the ones that got into hybrids early and whose normal lineup of cars are fuel efficient.
The Japanese workers have very strong labor rights and wages, as do the American workers who work in the Japanese factories here.
Southwest and Jetblue both have a unionized workforce yet they remain profitable.
The legacy airlines are still using circa 1960 business models built around the hub and spoke system. That's why they're losing money.
There are plenty of major retailers in the country who have a unionized workforce and they remain profitable.
If the government would do their job and raise minimum wage to 8.50 an hour then I'd agree that a union probably wouldn't be necessary for a company like Wal-Mart. However this congress and president won't do that because they're in the back pocket of companies like Wal-Mart.
So I think the workers should be able to get together and bargain for wages collectively.
Lenny
2006-02-23, 06:38 PM
Well nobody can say that this documentary isn't having an effect
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20060223/ap_on_bi_ge/wal_mart_health_care
pindilly
2006-02-24, 12:06 AM
I thought I might add to this pissing contest... I only have 2 points...
The first point is the slogan used by old man Sam when he started Sam's clubs and walmarts... The store was all american made products... after old man Sam's death ... Corperate Walton found better profit in international trade and markets... as well as labor...
and from personal experience... working at Florida's largest distrobution facility... supplying the stores located in most of the southeast region ... they have NO climate control and being right to work state... it is not manditory to provide heat or air... the quota for ALL package, shipping, or recieving departments is 110% ... if you get less then your 110% quote in your work day , you recieve a written warning, then a dock in pay, then suspension, then if you dont maintain at least 100% (which I think is the only possible quota that could be filled) your fired.
I worked as a forklift operater in shipping and made 8.25 per hour on 3rd shift, 8.25 was the shift pay increase from 7 per hour. after 6 months you were "eligible" for "up to" 1.00 of a raise till your 1 year anniversary. I was there for 4 months, got told my qouta was to low. I quit after my written warning for having a 102% quota.
The turnover ratio there was very high as a new crew starts every tuesday, 10 to 12 people. I was the last new employee till the next tuesday.
anyone who thinks walmart is a good thing ... needs to apply and work there... see for yourself...
RawAlex
2006-02-24, 12:53 AM
Lenny, you might want to read this:
http://www.wsws.org/articles/2005/mar2005/gmpr-m18.shtml
In the case of GM, $1800 out of every car sold goes to paying those costs.
Most people don't realize, but when GM or a Ford closes a plant, they are often stuck paying upwards to 80% of the salary costs anyway for years to come. There is very little flexibility in the process.
GM's sales and market share have dropped massively in the last 30 years, but they are still supporting the retirement benefits and (rapidly increasing) medical costs. Just last year, they have moved from 5.2 to 5.8 BILLION dollars. That change alone would cover 25% of the losses last year. Those costs continue to spiral and they are not going to go away until GM goes bankrupt, which is a solid possiblity.
Walmart would be non-functional with $15/hour stockboys and $20/hour fork lift drivers, especially if there were shop rules and legacy retirement costs to cover in the future. The impact at the cash register would kill (see K-mart).
Pindilly, I don't think anyone here is suggesting Walmart is a good career choice. Your experience with a tough work situation combined with (often over done) right to work laws means that it sucks ass. However, the truth is there, 10-12 new people come in every week to take a swing at it. That says enough.
Alex
Lenny
2006-02-24, 04:57 PM
Lenny, you might want to read this:
http://www.wsws.org/articles/2005/mar2005/gmpr-m18.shtml
In the case of GM, $1800 out of every car sold goes to paying those costs.
Most people don't realize, but when GM or a Ford closes a plant, they are often stuck paying upwards to 80% of the salary costs anyway for years to come. There is very little flexibility in the process.
GM's sales and market share have dropped massively in the last 30 years, but they are still supporting the retirement benefits and (rapidly increasing) medical costs. Just last year, they have moved from 5.2 to 5.8 BILLION dollars. That change alone would cover 25% of the losses last year. Those costs continue to spiral and they are not going to go away until GM goes bankrupt, which is a solid possiblity.
Walmart would be non-functional with $15/hour stockboys and $20/hour fork lift drivers, especially if there were shop rules and legacy retirement costs to cover in the future. The impact at the cash register would kill (see K-mart).
Pindilly, I don't think anyone here is suggesting Walmart is a good career choice. Your experience with a tough work situation combined with (often over done) right to work laws means that it sucks ass. However, the truth is there, 10-12 new people come in every week to take a swing at it. That says enough.
Alex
Alex I'm a reasonable guy, and I agree there are extremes involved on both sides of the argument.
I never said Wal-Mart should have $15 an hour stockboys. Don't inflate my position to make yours look more reasonable.
GM's problems are mostly due to their loss of market share, and that can't be blamed on the guy working the assembly line, the buck has to stop with management on that one.
(Although I do agree that things like the UAW JOBS bank are absurd)
There's also the issue of rising health care costs, which is another subject altogether that would take too long to go into here.
There is a vast array of social policies that I disagree with that cause these sorts of problems. The problem isn't just "Wal-Mart"
However, the minimum wage in this country, if it had been indexed to inflation would be around 8.50 an hour today.
Someone working full time making minimum wage only makes 2/3 of what it takes to cross the "poverty line"
What's the point in having a minimum wage if it doesn't at least keep people out of poverty?
Whenever anyone in congress brings up raising the minimum wage Wal-Mart is one of the first people in line with campaign and PAC contributions for any congressman who will oppose raising the minimum wage.
These are the sort of things that bother me. I think if a person works full time (in the richest country in the history of the world) that they should be able to feed themselves and see a doctor if they're sick. That's not too much to ask (unless you're Wal-Mart)
Raising wages and providing health insurance wouldn't hurt Wal-Mart's profitability one iota, yet they act as if it would put them into bankruptcy.
SirMoby
2006-02-24, 05:34 PM
The administration would have everyone in America working for a $1 an hour if they could tax that money and make claims on Fox News of having 0% unemployment.
If you raise minimum wage then people will loose jobs. Of course they're not feeding themselves at minimum wage so it's not a big lose but it looks bad on paper. The administration can not do something if the numbers look bad.
The real thing to do would be to cut taxes on minimum wage workers which would put more money in their pockets but then we'd need to raise taxes on the richest Americans, which is something else that the administration can't do.
Walmart has done some brilliant things in cutting costs but recently they've ran out of new ideas and paying off politicians to increase thier profits. We all know that.
RawAlex
2006-02-24, 06:01 PM
Lenny, the moves by the unions here in quebec would have seen hourly wages for "floor staff" increase at least 20% over the term of the contract, with major "shop rules" being put in place. It would not have been out of line to expect to see $15/hour staff stocking shelves, which just ain't gonna cut it at a discount retailer. No inflation of your position, it is what it is (the store was closed, now Walmart is being dragged in front of the labor relations board).
GM is suffering greatly from market share losses, but unlike a normal business that could easily adjust it's work force and manufacturing facilities, GM is bound be insane work rules, job counts, and legacy costs that pretty much wipe out any chance for a profit. Most of the contracts are written to maintain jobs and benefits, with few provisions for business down turns. GM is still paying for benefits granted in the 60's and 70's, long before competition came to the US market place. Yes, years of bad management and bad product have left them in a bad position, but Ford is also facing similar problems. The auto industry is one of the last big smoke stack industries that have survived in the US "as they were", but the pressure is there and something will give.
Minimum wage is a really difficult situation. If you make it too high, business cannot compete. If you make it too low, people cannot afford to live on that basic wage. A company like a WalMart of a McDonalds would not work the same way as it does if the basic wage paid got to be too high.
That you said there was a lineup of people wanting to work at Walmart new each week tells me that the job demand far outstrips the salary that is being paid. If the jobs were not acceptable, people wouldn't show up for them. It's pretty hard to arge supply and demand, even int he job market.
As for the medical issues, I think you need to look at your federal government to find out why this is a problem. Putting the weight of health care on individuals and companies is, in my mind, a major flaw of the United States, where more Americans live without health coverage than live without a car, a color TV, or a cell phone. Some things are just a little far out of whack.
Alex
Alex
vBulletin® v3.8.1, Copyright ©2000-2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.