Log in

View Full Version : Katrina aftermath - what the fuck???


dareutwo
2005-09-01, 02:50 PM
Ok, I don't normally respond to political issues, but this is simply a dead fucking wrong response.
See if you can spot 1 white person left in New Orleans???

Look folks, yeah, they were told to leave. But you know what, they don't have a car and simply can't leave! They couldn't afford one!!
You can't simply leave them there to die, (which they will).
They could supply Berlin with airlifts in WWII with supplies but they can't supply our own damn city?

I honestly don't know what the hell this administation is thinking.
Trust Me - there will be thousands and thousands of deaths.

Looting, flooding etc... Good thing we sent millions of dollars to New Orleans for an evacuation plan! Seems that money was well spent!

Get the people out of there, and call it a right off. Anything built below sea level from now on should be declined building permits period.

Bush, I have about as much faith in you as a rock.

Enough ranting, back to your regularly scheduled programming.

SirMoby
2005-09-01, 03:03 PM
Anything built below sea level from now on should be declined building permits period.Ever heard of The Netherlands? ;)

dareutwo
2005-09-01, 03:10 PM
SirMoby - yes I have, I was speaking of the US only, my apologies.
I don't think that Holland (Netherlands) have needed to survive a hurricane.

and btw- they have their plans together. The massive (millions of dollars) of closeable dikes, and what not.

Apparently, we just don't think that far in advance! :)

sue-fl
2005-09-01, 03:55 PM
Great point dareutwo got into the same discussion with some people last night. If your poor and your told to leave how do you??? They didn't send any one in to remove them which is such bullshit. Does it have any thing to do with the fact it is a poor area of blacks? Of couse it does. One lady said it right on CNN yesterday. Where was National Guard when we needed them? Oh thats right they are in Iraq!! All this aftermath would move so much smoother if we just brought our boys home. Help is needed to protect and save our own people.

Leon
2005-09-01, 04:04 PM
i just seen Bush at CNN , damn these guy looked scared, he cant handle the situation poor busterd

Halfdeck
2005-09-01, 04:06 PM
The thing is with every hurricane there are people who refuse to evac out of "it won't happen to me" attitude even when they own a car and have a tv set to hear about it days in advance.

Leon
2005-09-01, 04:12 PM
btw anyone knows whats up with SpaceManspiff (freepicsessex.com) and Rogue ?
as i remmember these guys from louisiana , and i didnt seen them goes online since katrina droped by, hope those guys are well

Bill
2005-09-01, 04:30 PM
It's Republican policy to let black people fend for themselves.

Except when it's Republican policy to treat them like criminals at police stops. (I'm referring to the recent Government Statistics officlal who quit when he was told to suppress a report that showed that whites and blacks were stopped by police at equivalent and essentially fair levels, but that after the stop, blacks and latino's were 80% more likely to be treated agressively, handcuffed, searched, and detained.)

Fortunately, emergencies like this will reveal Emporer Smirk's mismanagement.

Watch his Republican buddies run like rats from a sinking ship as this next year unfolds.

CelticTiger
2005-09-01, 04:34 PM
Anything built below sea level from now on should be declined building permits period.

Also, tho I'm not all that familiar with the construction methods over there but from what I can see is that timber framed houses are whats mostly constructed - concrete blocks should be mandatory in a hurricane prone zone.

Cleo
2005-09-01, 04:38 PM
It's just getting worse by the day. :(

I don't know if it is so much of a race thing as it is a case of the poor being the ones that are getting hurt the worst.

I don't know, it's just a big fucking horrible mess. :(

Leon
2005-09-01, 04:58 PM
are there any citizen or private movements that assist those people ?
i mean beside the national guard

Useless
2005-09-01, 05:09 PM
I'm more worried about the aftermath on a national level. Can our economy handle this?

If I was there, I wouldn't wait on my roof for more than 12 hours. I'd float my pungent ass to land and then keep on going. Those poor fuckers have nothing left, nothing to return to. It's like they were just born into the world at the age of 30, with no possessions, no work, no direction, nothing.

Leon
2005-09-01, 05:12 PM
isnt fixing all the houses and the city suppose to create new work places ?

Surfn
2005-09-01, 05:16 PM
I've donated money to the Red Cross for the hurricane victims. I also sponsor a local Red Cross class to train volunteers that want to go to the affected areas.

Ramster
2005-09-01, 05:24 PM
spacemanspif and jenny are from Baton Rouge I think. Haven't heard from them myself.

docholly
2005-09-01, 05:28 PM
yahoo seems to have a problem with verbiage.. let me see if i can find the links..

"black people loot" (http://news.yahoo.com/photo/050830/480/ladm10208301530)

"White people find" (http://news.yahoo.com/photo/050830/photos_ts_afp/050830071810_shxwaoma_photo1)

The thing is.. how many of us would be able to evacuate in a 12 hour time span? If we didn't have transportation? Or the money to get on a plane? or the money to get on a bus/train etc? Let's face it, a large percentage of this country lives literally from pay check to pay check. or could access ready cash on a sunday other than the 300.00 limit from an ATM?

The sad part is that so many people in this country live like this because they don't have the comprehension that there is a way to get out.

I doubt seriously this will reflect on George. I think he's going to thump his bible and say "the lord's will" or some other bull shit.. when actually Mother Nature is PISSED that he declared there is No Global warming.. but she didn't want to hit Cindy in Crawford.

|angry|

Leon
2005-09-01, 05:31 PM
is Baton Rouge was also visited by Katrina ?

dareutwo
2005-09-01, 05:49 PM
I'm more worried about the aftermath on a national level. Can our economy handle this?


If we can finance a war on your childrens wages. I think we can afford getting the people out.
I think GW got his new Amex Gold card when taking office.
I don't know about rebuilding the whole damn area, just get the people out.

Diesel Engines do not short out... Where are the tractors from that area? 10' of water isn't a problem on hard roads. Get the farmers in there. At least they have some common sense.

In the meantime, airdrop whatever is needed. This isn't rocket science.

And Yes btw - I DO think it's a race thing.

th3g4me
2005-09-01, 06:07 PM
They are all red states down there... You think Bush would have really wanted to take care of them in something like this. This will be bad for the republican party...

I don’t understand why the people are shooting at the choppers that come in to supply them, take them out, and try to repair the levees. Just because they stole them selves some new guns doesn’t mean they have to use them.

Chop Smith
2005-09-01, 06:13 PM
This is not a political issue. It is not a racial issue. The people of the south will pull together and we will rise again.

You saw the national TV coverage and saw color. As a life long Mississippian, I see the TV coverage and I see fellow Southerns in trouble.

Torn Rose
2005-09-01, 06:28 PM
Since this is the most recent katrina thread I will post this here.

Fats Domino was missing Thursday, days after Hurricane Katrina devastated New Orleans, said his longtime agent, Al Embry. Embry told The Associated Press that he hadn't been able to contact Domino since talking to him Sunday evening by phone.

The 77-year-old R&B legend, whose real name is Antoine Domino, told Embry that he planned to stay at his New Orleans house with his wife, Rosemary, and their daughter.

"I hope somebody turns him up, but as of right now, we haven't got anybody that knows where he's at," said Embry, who has worked with Domino for 28 years. "I would think he might be safe because somebody said he was on top of the balcony."

Checquoline Davis, Domino's niece, posted a message on Craigslist.com Thursday pleading for information. Davis wrote that Domino, his wife, their children and grandchildren "didn't get out" of the second floor.

Domino, who has rarely appeared in public in recent years, has a home in the 9th ward, a low-lying area of the flooded city.

Getting information on possible missing persons has been nearly impossible as phone lines for hospitals and police haven't been working.

Domino has sold more than 110 million records in his long career, including the legendary singles "Blueberry Hill" and "Ain't That a Shame."

th3g4me
2005-09-01, 06:37 PM
I think it would be much better if they used race, or class of income for a reason they are not getting help as they need it…

To call it a southern thing is weird, as is calling it a political issue... Seeing as how the same hurricane went through the state of the president's brother and killed people, also it hit a state that boarders the presidents home. His political base is in the south. It is the area hit by the hurricane.

sue-fl
2005-09-01, 07:02 PM
Yes it does seem to be a racial issue to me also. It's just sad that it has come to this in light of such a tradegy. Sure help is on it's way, people will get moved out of there into safer places. I agree with Chop Smith that they will rebound. I just think if the poor had been moved out like they should have before the storm it wouldn't be so bad. What the hell was the local goverment thinking in not bringing the buses in before hand instead of scrambling now?? It was on the news as soon as the storm left Florida it was going to be a big problem.

I think dochollys post about how black take and white find is what angers me so much. It's the news that help spread this kind of stuff that angers so many and starts trouble. Sure the black poor citizens were over looked which is unforgiveable. But why add to it by reporting shit like they did on yahoo??
I don't care if a person is black, white, purple etc.. they could have stop a lot of whats going on if they had just got them out.....before |angry|

I just wish there was something I could do to help.

emmanuelle
2005-09-01, 09:29 PM
The south will rise again, just like Atlanta.
Southerners are incredibly proud and independant

Hurricanes Cindy and Dennis were expected to be severe, and did not live up to their hype. When the warnings came for Katrina, they were not taken seriously enough.

Forget about racism, who is at fault and everything else that armchair analysts seem to be preoccupied with. Get yourself over to the redcross site (http://www.redcross.org/) and see what you can do to be part of the solution. Hundreds of thousands of people have been affected in that region alone, not to mention the entire continent's economy.

Everyone joined together when 9-11 happened, and even for the tsunami crisis. America needs to pull itself together again for one of it's own. The longer we argue and delay help, the more people who die.

Bill
2005-09-01, 09:49 PM
I think it's absolutely a political issue. And it will become hugely more so as the repercussions of this event unfold.

People have known NO was a disaster waiting to happen for a long, long time.

But, there will be time enough for the politics of this in the future. Investigations will tell us a great deal.

It's going to be a hellish night for those folks. Hopefully tomorrow the relief trucks will arrive.

Tubey
2005-09-01, 09:49 PM
I recently started on a quest to help, My goal was to create a list of shelters and possibley the names of people within to help locate family members separated and sheltered in different locations. I called alot of people today and this was the result....

-----Original Message-----
From: Specenl1@aol.com [mailto:Specenl1@aol.com]
Sent: Thursday, September 01, 2005 2:10 PM
To:
Subject: Making of website list from Terry

Hello,

I am trying to make a list of people located in shelters so other family members can locate loved ones during the disaster. I do some web work and purchased the domain shelterlist.com to try to accomplish this task. The domain will not be active for a few more hours and so far I have contacted the coast guard, fema, and have tried to contact the redcross to get some sort of list started. At this time fema has no such list, nor does the coast guard, I am hoping the redcross may have some information that would start this process.
I can be contacted through this e-mail address
Thanks for any input you can give,
Terry

Terry,
The American Red Cross does not post the names of individuals located in shelters due to confidentiality reasons.
Take care.
American Red Cross of Central Florida


I still have some people trying to figure out a way to get the info about the shelters but it seems this may be very difficult at this point.
ANY IDEAS???
Terry

docholly
2005-09-01, 10:05 PM
Moveon.org has a website called Hurricane Housing (http://www.hurricanehousing.org/) which lists shelters, organizations and families that are offering short and long term shelter. Even tho we are in vegas we added ours as we have a spare room and who knows.. at least vegas has jobs.

Also Craigslist.org is posting information for NOLA and surrounding areas about housing, food, jobs etc and i think they were starting a "here is where I am" list.. for those who are looking kind of like what they did after 9-11.

emmanuelle
2005-09-01, 10:14 PM
There are several regional message boards where people can post the names of the missing, as well as get out word that they are safe and where they have evacuated to.
Many are associated with local newspapers, and cnn has one as well
try these:
http://forums.sunherald.com/n/mb/listsf.asp?webtag=kr-biloxkatrina
http://www.nola.com/forums/searching/
http://208.137.136.144/phpbb2/index.php
http://www.cnn.com/SPECIALS/2005/hurricanes/list/
http://kenburtonne.web116.discountasp.net/Katrina/Status.aspx

Here is the official gov site listing most resources http://www.firstgov.gov/Citizen/Topics/PublicSafety/Hurricane_Katrina_Recovery.shtml#vgn-finding-loved-ones-vgn

Chop Smith
2005-09-01, 10:29 PM
Nice post, Emmauelle. Thanks.

Good video of the damage at http://www.wlbt.com/

Tubey
2005-09-01, 10:33 PM
Thanks,
I will get those links up as soon as the dns resolves and I will pass the info on.
Terry

SirMoby
2005-09-02, 12:32 AM
I'm more worried about the aftermath on a national level. Can our economy handle this?
My thought is NO. I never thought that the economy could handle another 4 years of Dubya even without this.

It will be 2006 before people can have drinkable running water in homes but these people have guns now.

Those that know me know that I would love to blame the administration for this but it's not easy.

Think about a bill presented by the senator of Lousiana for $250,000,000 to build damns in his state. How is he going to get the support of CA, NY or any other state blue or red? He ain't and it don't matter what 100 reports says. He ain't gonna get it.

Blame the administration for starting the war in Iraq, giving huge amounts of tax dollars to friends and family and spending more then our great grand children can repay. You can blame the administration for not being able to provide support in a week to 10 days but voters would not allow them to spend the 100s of millions of dollars needed to keep that city above water.

I don't think it's a racial issue but the news will make it so. It's about money and power and NO never had enough of either to keep he city above water.

Halfdeck
2005-09-02, 01:56 AM
The south will rise again, just like Atlanta.
Southerners are incredibly proud and independant

Hurricanes Cindy and Dennis were expected to be severe, and did not live up to their hype. When the warnings came for Katrina, they were not taken seriously enough.

Forget about racism, who is at fault and everything else that armchair analysts seem to be preoccupied with. Get yourself over to the redcross site (http://www.redcross.org/) and see what you can do to be part of the solution. Hundreds of thousands of people have been affected in that region alone, not to mention the entire continent's economy.

Everyone joined together when 9-11 happened, and even for the tsunami crisis. America needs to pull itself together again for one of it's own. The longer we argue and delay help, the more people who die.

Well said. I admit I'm not overly charitable by nature, but I cruised on over to redcross.org (http://www.redcross.org/) and donated after reading your post.

Useless
2005-09-02, 02:25 AM
The more I watch the coverage, the more it saddens me to see that our government is, for all intents and purposes, allowing people to starve and to die from dehydration. This is one sorry state of affairs. You cannot tell me that there is no way to reach these people. If a damned news crew can film them, then why can't the national guard get in there with food and water? It's sad that it requires armed people to restore order, but that's what happens when you allow people to feel abandoned. Mob rules will always take over in the absense of authority.

spookyx
2005-09-02, 02:37 AM
The more I watch the coverage, the more it saddens me to see that our government is, for all intents and purposes, allowing people to starve and to die from dehydration. This is one sorry state of affairs. You cannot tell me that there is no way to reach these people. If a damned news crew can film them, then why can't the national guard get in there with food and water? It's sad that it requires armed people to restore order, but that's what happens when you allow people to feel abandoned. Mob rules will always take over in the absense of authority.

so true UW. and about the guns... if my family was stuck and starving, I would prolly grab one too.

|peace|

Kinky
2005-09-02, 02:48 AM
The more I watch the coverage, the more it saddens me to see that our government is, for all intents and purposes, allowing people to starve and to die from dehydration. This is one sorry state of affairs. You cannot tell me that there is no way to reach these people. If a damned news crew can film them, then why can't the national guard get in there with food and water? It's sad that it requires armed people to restore order, but that's what happens when you allow people to feel abandoned. Mob rules will always take over in the absense of authority.

one reason is that most of our national guard is in Iraq fighting for "freedom" and dubya isn't smart enough to figure out where to get the manpower to help...

it was also nice to see him take a low pass real quick over in air force one to check the damage instead of actually giving two shits and getting in a chopper and visiting the damaged area... so many people said he was "a great leader" after 9/11 well what the fuck happened? he is a friggin' retard with a perma smirk |angry|

Tubey
2005-09-02, 03:20 AM
one reason is that most of our national guard is in Iraq fighting for "freedom" and dubya isn't smart enough to figure out where to get the manpower to help...

it was also nice to see him take a low pass real quick over in air force one to check the damage instead of actually giving two shits and getting in a chopper and visiting the damaged area... so many people said he was "a great leader" after 9/11 well what the fuck happened? he is a friggin' retard with a perma smirk |angry|

It is taking longer than it should but you just can't send in 30k troops onto bourbon st, you have to know where to send them to make them effective. The devastation doesn't just start at NO either most of the roads are AFU to get them there. It does take a little time to get the troops called in and loaded up planned out as far as where they are going to sleep and how they are going to get fed as well. The airport is being used to stage rescue ops of the living if the pres stopped there it would hault operations (due to security reasons) for hours while he was there and I don't believe anyone would like to stop rescue ops so I believe he made the right choice not to stop in and take a peek. Tues the Coast Guard alone did over 1700 rescue missions not including the other branches of the service. In short the whole area is a mess and it is a HUGE mess. Roads are destroyed bridges out, people shooting, looting, and running around like crazy. I think this is the first time since the civil war that an entire city was ever evacuated.
I think we should figure out how to fix the problem not who to blame.
Just my $.02

Trev
2005-09-02, 03:31 AM
one reason is that most of our national guard is in Iraq fighting for "freedom" and dubya isn't smart enough to figure out where to get the manpower to help...
Exactly. I heard they were calling up Coast Guard reserves. Even that takes time. They have a huge hospital ship coming. From Baltimore.................... it should be there in 3-4 days. Everything should be there in 2-4 days..... but meanwhile.......

Ms Naughty
2005-09-02, 04:02 AM
There are two white guys left in New Orleans and they seem to have the only beer:
http://sigmund.biz/kat20050901%20part%202/Picture137.jpg
(Pic taken from the DirectNIC photo pages here: http://sigmund.biz/kat20050901%20part%202/)

Yahoo has taken the "white people find" photo down but there's copies and commentary at Salon:
http://www.salon.com/news/feature/2005/09/01/photo_controversy/index.html

I also read a news report where a black man said he considered driving his family out before the storm hit but he only had a five- person car and heard the people were being arrested for overloading cars.

:/

dareutwo
2005-09-02, 06:48 AM
Just an fyi before you think I'm a complete moron - (well ok, some of you still will think so)
I did donate to the Red Cross for this on Tuesday night.
My brother and father of 4, a combat medic, is on stand by (National Guard) to fly down from Minnesota.
I have also called my local Representative.
I did call both my Senators (had to leave messages), and have done everything I could do from here.
This is simply just a complete frickin mess.
NO lies below sea level, this has been known for decades, yet they had no plan???

I have no doubt that the "South" will rebuild, but that's not the question now. The immediate question should be (and have been), "Get those people out now".

juggernaut
2005-09-02, 11:02 AM
From my vast experience in the military and federal employment and working with the National Guard I have to say those guys have it harder then any other military. Not only from the stand point of having a day job but also from the command sense. They take their orders from the state level. Meaning, even if GW sent them to war your State's governor has the power to stop that. Even more so in the mid-east (NYC NJ ETC) if the governor feels it’s too important to take "His/her" troops then he can say no they are not going. But on the other hand you are dealing with a political nightmare. Any Governor to say such a thing would just be looked at as not wanting to fight this war.
So 70% of there air craft are in other places through out the world, we know this. The problem is stemming from most NG who would help with this are the ones who live there. Now on other issues that come from this100% of all soldiers are ruled by UCMJ military law, which is enforced at the DOD level. Now what that means is if a soldier gets orders, those orders are coming from the President. If they disobey those orders, they go to jail (that’s active military). The National Guard is ruled by UCMJ but it's not enforced on a federal level. In other words someone in the NG can get orders, but they would come from his governor. And if they disobey those orders the UCMJ CAN be enforced but it does not have to. The ending decision comes from that’s NG TAG (like their 5 start general, governors military advisor). You will find that most NG does not enforce these rules for a couple of reasons. Most of the soldiers in the NG are long time soldiers, lifers. The average experience level of these soldiers is 18 years in the military. Most of that time is over 10 in the NG. So the TAG's understand what it means to have a day job and deal with the military. They will not stop a man from trying to help his family. If someone from the NG got orders and never showed up, they would get in trouble but most likely just a slap on the wrist. These are not your normal military families; they don't live on bases or live the military life 100%. So for them family comes 1st and no governor or tag is going to put someone in jail for helping his family, even more so if the soldier is a good solider, never having any infractions. Worst part about this is, that most NG soldiers are better then the active military. Nothing against them, it's just the numbered facts. They have a long military experience and training (most train active military), and when sent to schools it’s a hardship on the family for a few months, it's also hard for a NG to get the schooling as all military schools require some kind of physical training test in order to pass the school. The NG will not send a solider to school for promotion or anything if they feel they will fail the PT test. So when they do go they are ready. Plus the state flips that bill and if the soldier fails the school its money wasted. So now you have guys with all these years of experience (most experts in their field, you would be surprised the amount of doctors and lawyers in the Guard) who can't or won't show up to help because they are trying to help their families. I'm sure GW is getting a reminder of what it means to not show up for training or anything else in the NG. I mean he surly remembers he did not have to. I personally would have gone. I know the NG would have helped its family first so their soldiers can work with the comfort of knowing the family is safe. But when no one shows up to drive that boat or fly the chopper where do you get the skilled labor from? Sorry for the long one. Jugg.

emmanuelle
2005-09-02, 11:54 AM
NO lies below sea level, this has been known for decades, yet they had no plan???



Does California have an earthquake plan?

Calliope
2005-09-02, 11:56 AM
My question is where are all our "international" friends? Food and water was dropped 2 days after the tsunami, its now day 5 and no massive water/food drop?

Where to put the people? - Isn't the gulf full of cruise ships? Isn't NO on the Gulf? At least they would have shelter and get them out of the city until permenant shelters could be etablished in other areas.

This whole things rips my heart out - I have many friends who live(d) in and round NO. Little by little we are finding them safe.

dareutwo
2005-09-02, 11:31 PM
Does California have an earthquake plan?

For the "Big One", yes they do, but unfortunately it's plan is based on California moving 20-25 miles north in about 1 minute, and the Home Base Operations is in Colorado :(

Calliope - GW turned down all offers of assistance so far.

Erick G
2005-09-03, 02:21 AM
USA is too arogant to ask for help
which is fucken SAD but true.
Canada has sent rescue teams.
Countries have donated money.. I dont have the list in front of me.. but its getting big.
Bush is creating one hell of a legacy.. King of incompetence!
5 days to send help in..ridiculous! American's DESERVE fucken anwsers!

docholly
2005-09-03, 10:23 AM
man i nearly punched this guy in the grocery line yesterday. Apparently when the few supplies finally arrived yesterday, AFTER George was there, (i'm surprised he didn't ride in on the top of one of the trucks).. there were quite a few angry words for the soldiers.

Well this asshole |angry| was kvetching.. about see we sent in food and they are still bitching. Loudly! (and other racial crap that I refuse to repeat)

I said to him: Excuse me but this store cannot sell you food for the next 5 days. He looked at me dumb struck. I said.. see you need to feel thirsty, hungry, tired and HOT with no communication from the outside world, surrounded by rotting dead people, sewage that has been left in 97% humidity for 5 days. ONLY then will you understand exactly WHY these people are angry.

He said they should have left. I said.. and left how? Walked? ridden a bicycle in 120MPH winds? did the national guard drive through the neighborhoods before hand offering rides? NO.. but they did get the tourists out.

well it resulted in an ensuing shouting match with about 6 people participating.. finally i just said in my normal voice.. See it is really all about content of character. Left my groceries in the cart and kept on stepping. |angry|

As bill maher said last night: George hugged a Negro today, now we can let the supply trucks in. (paraphrased cuz i was 1/2 asleep)

Tommy
2005-09-03, 11:37 AM
this whole thing is bullshit

5 days before any real supplies or troops get there ???

think about as if this was your town

saying that they didnt know where to go was bullshit they could just turn on cnn see the people on their roofs and point and say go there

I will tell ya one thing i noticed....... white people know when to leave

I also dont think its fair to place all the blame on George Bush


but I seen on cnn GW was talking with fema leaders and who ever was in charge of the coast gaurd

he didnt know the cameras were on him, and he had that same stupid look on his face as he did at the school during 9/11. He just kept noding his head looking like an idiot

this guy is not a leader

spookyx
2005-09-03, 06:48 PM
and what a lot of people have not yet thought about... what happens to the people that did get out. no jobs or homes to return too. pretty soon people that made it to hotels and such far away are going to run out of money and need help too. its like a million people unemployed at once.

|peace|

emmanuelle
2005-09-03, 07:13 PM
More than a million- Already my parent's company (based in Laurel MS) is in jeopardy.
Without power, internet or staff, they cannot bill clients, or pay their out of town employees. They still cannot get flights out of Jackson to generate revenue either.

A week or two of downtime can ruin many businesses; I expect to see many southern companies close in the near future.

RawAlex
2005-09-03, 07:23 PM
The thing that disturbs me the most is pictures on one side of people trapped in their homes and stuck in various parts of New Orleans because they couldn't get out, and on the other side pictures of hundreds of school buses and city buses mid window deep in water, never moved to the service of these people.

In a city with a huge population of low income people who likely don't have transportation to get out of the city, I think the city (mayor and others) made a major mistake by not getting these busses on the roads and out picking people up.

Even at 50 people per bus, thousands of people could have been moved to higher ground before this turned to shit.

It's the little things that piss me off - because a collection of little things could have changed everything.

Tommy
2005-09-04, 11:50 AM
if you really think about the job situation its really fucked

its gonna be 3 months before they start letting people back in

so 3 months before buisness can start rebuilding
who knows maybe 2 months to rebuild ??
but who is gonna rebuild when there are no jobs, which = no money

if you reopen your resturant nobody has any money to come and order food, drinks etc

dareutwo
2005-09-04, 04:51 PM
so 3 months before buisness can start rebuilding
who knows maybe 2 months to rebuild ??
but who is gonna rebuild when there are no jobs, which = no money


I'm guessing a lot longer than that. When Andrew hit Florida, plywood prices 1800 miles away almost tripled. (and we make it here)
They don't have an infrastructure to build onto. All the gas, power, phones etc, no longer exist. What are you going to hook up too??
This will take years.

I would keep the people out for as long as it takes to have the really big equipment to get their jobs done. ie... don't allow them back for maybe a year. During that time, let the dozers and big crews get the heavy lifting done. It's a lot easier to tear up and replace a road when you don't have to detour or reroute traffic or worry about live wires, just tear it up and build.
If a 12 man crew can install the infrastructure to a new 50 house sub division in about 8-10 weeks, imagine what 15,000 National Guard, the SeeBeas and huge equipment can get done. They can work 24 hours a day.

Erick G
2005-09-04, 05:46 PM
It is going to take 60-80 days just to drain the water which is beyond contaminated
Its going to take YEARS at the pace this gov moves for people to rebuild.

furrygirl
2005-09-04, 10:52 PM
My question is where are all our "international" friends? Food and water was dropped 2 days after the tsunami, its now day 5 and no massive water/food drop?

Where to put the people? - Isn't the gulf full of cruise ships? Isn't NO on the Gulf? At least they would have shelter and get them out of the city until permenant shelters could be etablished in other areas.

I've read about Qatar pledging 100m to relief, as well as Castro sending doctors: http://neworleans.indymedia.org/news/2005/09/4260.php & http://www.cnn.com/2005/WEATHER/09/03/katrina.castro/

Plus, the government has hired 3 Carnival cruise ships to provide temporary housing.

Lemmy
2005-09-04, 11:24 PM
"apart from the million dollars in monetary assistance, Venezuela is offering two mobile hospital units, each capable of assisting 150 people, 120 specialists in rescue operations, 10 water purifying plants, 18 electricity generators of 850 KW each, 20 tons of bottled water, and 50 tons of canned food"

US response? Unsolicited offers can be counter productive.

http://bellaciao.org/en/article.php3?id_article=8012

CaptainJSparrow
2005-09-05, 12:05 AM
Hi Guys,

I'm from Louisiana...Baton Rouge to be exact. I "snuck in" to New Orleans this morning with my brother to check on his house. Normally, I don't get involved with "political speak." This time, I think I'll add my 2 cents.

First off, Leon, Spaceman Spiff & Jenny are fine. They got their power back on late last night, but their internet connection is still down. Obviously I'm (you called me Rogue...my icq handle) fine too...my power was off until Thursday night.

Let me tell you, don't don't get too caught up in all this crap that they're showing on the news. First, we had very little warning of this pending storm because no one knew where it was going...we can't run everytime there is a storm in the gulf.

Second, our contra flow for traffic worked exceptionally well...everyone willing and able to get out of New Orleans did.

Now these folks that stayed, and everyone is blaming the government for that...alot of them are too stupid, or in too much of a drug/alcohol induced stupor, to bother trying to get out. AND, since when did it become the government's, or the president's responsibility to force people to do something that they refuse to do for their own health? I mean, when do adults actually have take responsibility for their own situations and their own health and well-being? Everyone complains about big brother...then when something like this happens they complain that that same big brother should have done something about it. You can't have it both ways. This is a free country and those folks chose to live in New Orleans, knowing that it is below sea level. The majority of them chose to stay in their domiciles as well. They could have gone to the 'Dome or other places.

I've seen first hand TONS of busses going to New Orleans to get these folks out. I've seen the helicopters flying all over. At the New Orleans airport, there were lots of planes and helicopters flying folks out. Busses everywhere. Police from all over the country too. National guardsmen...on I-10 there were hundreds of trucks.

Let me tell you, what could have been a life ending disaster of "Biblical proportions" was missed because of the quick response of the authorities...both local, statewide, and national.

It pisses me off when the national media come in here and fly around filming (and playing the same film clips over and over and over again) the aforementioned folks and throwing blame at the government. These few unlucky folks are the exception, not the rule...and for the most part, they brought it on themselves.

Then you have idiots like Jesse Jackson begging for attention and ranting and raving that it's racism. Pardon my French, but Fuck him! He's just trying to get attention and incite unrest.

I drove around today, went to the Lake, saw some houses that had water damage...hell it's nothing that we folks from around here haven't seen before. I'm kinda surprised that folks from Biloxi, Mobile, Pensacola, and Miami aren't flipping everyone off and saying "Hello! We get this shit all the time." Yes, a large part of New Orleans got hit hard. It's under sea level and that makes it a bit more disastrous. It's nothing that can't be dealt with. Mark my words, they're gonna rebuild it better than it was before and faster than the national media leads you to believe.

We've had phone problems because of the vast amount of folks in one area. We've had lines at the gas pumps. We've had tons of people without power. But the great majority of us are alive and well. Real estate around here is skyrocketing. Landlords are giving their tenants the boot and selling their properties. Homeowners are raising the selling price of their houses because of the boom. There are no apartments for rent, no hotel rooms available. Jobs in this part of Louisiana are guaranteed for quite a while.

New Orleans will be rebuilt...my only regret is that those folks that scream "the sky is falling and it's someone's fault" can't be buried under the cement of those new structures that we will build. It'd be a great resting place for Jesse Jackson and lots of other folks that always throw stones without knowing what they're talking about.

Our government, President Bush, no one is responsible for this hurricane. It is a natural disaster. IMHO everyone has done a great job in helping folks survive.

CaptainJSparrow
2005-09-05, 12:21 AM
One more thing, word around here is that Fats Domino is staying at Jamarcus Russell's (the quarterback for LSU) place. Not sure if it's true or not, but I think that it is.

Lemmy
2005-09-05, 12:41 AM
First of all, I'm glad the board members are safe.

I can't respond to everything you said, it's too late and I'm tired, but fuck man you're heartless. They're too dumb to get out, so it serves them right?

Regarding your big brother comment, you can and should have it "both ways". The reason governments are created in the first place (in democracies) is to provide basic safety for the citizens, but at the same time stay out of or private affairs. Hurricane relief seems like a prime example of what any self-respecting government should provide.

Chop Smith
2005-09-05, 12:56 AM
Amen, Captain. But ain't it great to be from the most mis-understood region in America?

I don't think this has hit the news yet. Down on the Mississipi Gulf Coast, they are constructing a fence to block the public out. By Wednesday they hope to have the body count finished and the Mississippi National Guard, local and state agencies will begin dozering everything south of the railroad tracks. We are getting ready to rebuilt. This is not the first time and I am sure it will not be the last.

CaptainJSparrow
2005-09-05, 01:17 AM
Lemmy, I never said "it serves them right." My point is, they should take it upon themselves to watch out for themselves...we can't blame the government for all of our problems. I mean, should the government take away all of our kitchen knives because some folks use them to hurt themselves, to commit suicide, or to commit murder? Alot of these people REFUSED to get out. Then, you see them waving flags on the news and say it's the governments fault. Hopefully, those white flags that they're waving will be flags of surrender saying "Ok, next time they say leave, re: MANDATORY EVACUATION, I will take it upon myself to go to a designated place of shelter, catch a ride, do something to get the hell out of there.

You know, my uncle told me that he wasn't evacuating...he said that his house had withstood hurricanes for 26 years. At 1 am on Monday he told my aunt, that if they survive this one they will never stay when there is an evacuation again. I almost begged him on the phone to evacuate. Thankfully they survived, with just minimal damage to their house.

I agree that in a perfect world the government should do as you mentioned. This world is not perfect. As free citizens, we should take it upon ourselves to be as responsible for our own well being as is humanly possible. IMHO these folks did nothing of the kind...they thumbned their noses at the government, and it's warnings, and now they're paying the price for their actions.

I've seen first hand that the government is responding. I've seen the military already involved. I've seen the police from lots of other states. I've seen the commandeered busses. I know of one company that chartered a number of busses to go get some of their employees and the government commandeered those busses... it basically said, your people are Ok where they are (ie they'll live) so we are taking these busses to help get out folks that are in more danger. I also know, for a fact, that one company had some employees that voluntarily stayed to "mind the store". As the water started rising because of the broken levee, they got worried. The company hired helicopters to go get the employees. The plan was to land on the top of the Tulane Medical Center's Parking garage (which has a heliport). The guard there, freaked out because of the national media's predictions of rioting, refused to let these employees get to the helicopters. These guards even flagged away the helicopters. Our governor called in and told these people to let those helicopters land. The employees were flown to private jets and taken to safety.

C'mon now, again, sure it's a disaster, sure some folks got killed. It is sad, but it is a part of life. I just say, that the majority of folks that got killed, they could've avoided it had they listened to the government. Hence, it is their own fault.

CaptainJSparrow
2005-09-05, 01:24 AM
By the way, I'm not involved with politics at all. I pretty much hate politics. I'm not fanatically pro-republican or pro-democrat.

I am a big believer in people taking responsibility for themselves as much as possible and think that most folks should stop trying to blame others for their woes.

I think a smaller, better organized, less involved (in our personal lives) government would be much better.

I guess I'm trying to say that I really am not "pro-government" by any means.

In this instance, I think that they did an admirable job. I think that the national media paints as grim a picture as possible for viewers/ratings.

Good night all.

Tubey
2005-09-05, 02:24 AM
I recently started on a quest to help, My goal was to create a list of shelters and possibley the names of people within to help locate family members separated and sheltered in different locations. I called alot of people today and this was the result....

-----Original Message-----
From: Specenl1@aol.com [mailto:Specenl1@aol.com]
Sent: Thursday, September 01, 2005 2:10 PM
To:
Subject: Making of website list from Terry

Hello,

I am trying to make a list of people located in shelters so other family members can locate loved ones during the disaster. I do some web work and purchased the domain shelterlist.com to try to accomplish this task. The domain will not be active for a few more hours and so far I have contacted the coast guard, fema, and have tried to contact the redcross to get some sort of list started. At this time fema has no such list, nor does the coast guard, I am hoping the redcross may have some information that would start this process.
I can be contacted through this e-mail address
Thanks for any input you can give,
Terry

Terry,
The American Red Cross does not post the names of individuals located in shelters due to confidentiality reasons.
Take care.
American Red Cross of Central Florida


I still have some people trying to figure out a way to get the info about the shelters but it seems this may be very difficult at this point.
ANY IDEAS???
Terry

Guess What? I guess they do..... and they totally took the Idea and ran with it.
Don't get me wrong the red cross is and has done many wonderfull things around the world....but a little credit for the idea would be nice.......

Linkster
2005-09-05, 08:34 AM
Capt Sparrow - as you know I echo everything you are saying 10 times over - we all know down here what is really going on and all I can say is that if people want to watch the news I sure hope they understand they are getting "tainted reporting"

Im really glad to hear that you guys are ok and S Spiff and the others are doing good - sounds like things are about the same down there as they are here other than the real estate boom :)

I can get some deisel for the truck so if you need anything carted down let me know - if anyone needs a place to get away from the hub-bub for a few days Ive got plenty of room here - or if you have a trailer or boat you need storage for - plenty of parking area

Lemmy
2005-09-05, 09:40 AM
Well I don't live in Louisiana or anywhere near the South, so I don't know what's really going on. I can't insert myself into the minds of thousands of victims to see why they didn't evacuate and pass moral judgement on their need for help.

But I can pass moral judgement on the quality of a society. I do so in part by seeing how it responds to those in need wether or not they 'deserve' it.

CaptainJSparrow
2005-09-05, 11:20 AM
Thanks Linkster. We're good here though. Glad to hear that you're OK too.

Lemmy. I realize that it is easy to form an opinion, and pass judgement, on things. The hard part is to realize that some of the information that you're using to form that opinion is tainted (as Linkster said) by the media.

In this instance, I read the posts and thought that some folks had the wrong opinion (based on what I've seen first hand and on what my friends have seen and we've discussed).

I know of a man that was delivering water and ice to help, and his truck with all the supplies was carjacked at gunpoint by the very same people that he was trying to help.

Folks have volunteered to go down there in their own boats to rescue these poor folks that you're talking about, and these same poor folks are shooting at their rescuers, and even taking the boats themselves.

Military helicopters are being shot at as they try to rescue people.

You know, when "we" clear out land and there are wild animals living on that land we re-locate them. The people that go in, have to take the proper precautions and wear protective clothing, etc. to protect themselves from the animals that they're trying to help. Even though it's in the animals best interest that they be relocated, they still bite the hand that's trying to save them.

Well, unfortunately, in New Orleans, a similar thing is going on. The military, the police, and the volunteers jobs are being slowed down by the folks that they are trying to rescue. There are alot of people in New Orleans that don't want to be rescued/re-located. They would rather stay and have their way (ie loot) with as many stores as they can. But once these folks get caught somewhere because of rising water, they're on TV waving flags and nice folks are saying "It's the President's fault that those poor folks are still in New Orleans." Now of course, that is not an accurate description of every person waving a flag...but I'd guess that everything that I've typed in these posts describes well over 95% of those folks that you're seeing on TV. Yesterday, as I was driving around an area that was just a block or two from the Lake, an area that had flooded, I saw a man sitting in the median on a lawn chair getting some sun and watching everything going on around him. There was no way that he has any sort of power where he was. I'm doubting that he had running water...if it ran it was certainly not drinkable. There were cars and trucks driving all around this man. If he wanted to get out, he could've flagged one of us down and someone would have taken him to safety. Instead, he sat there watching the ducks and the traffic and the storm damage. Now, should the President come on down and forceably remove this guy? He doesn't want to go. What if it rains here tomorrow, the levee breaks where he is, and he's on his roof waving a flag? The media helicopters will be flying over him (not offering assistance) and broadcasting his image all over the world and who will folks blame for this poor guy's predicament?

Most people around here know that the contra flow worked. The mandatory evactuation, in the order that they did it, worked. Most people around here know that those folks that are dead or stranded did it to themselves. We feel sorry for them, to an extent. Alot of folks around here also feel that these people are keeping the authorities from focusing on repairing the damage.

Lemmy, that is just how it really is down here in Louisiana.

Lemmy
2005-09-05, 11:43 AM
So now you're comparing the victims to wild animals?

Why don't we just file this whole thing under "Shit Happens" and move on with our lives. I'll call the Red Cross and ask for a refund on my donation. After all this didn't happen in Connecticut so why should I give a shit?

No disrespect CaptainJSparrow, but your analogies seem a bit off.

Agreed, opinions are easy to form and as we know everybody has one. I also realize that media thrives on shit, but you just can't explain away the past week's coverage from every major news outlet in the world.

Best of luck to everyone in the affected areas!

CaptainJSparrow
2005-09-05, 12:00 PM
Lemmy, there's an old saying "If it walks like a duck, quacks like a duck, and has an orange bill..."

You keep calling them victims. If someone brings something upon himself or herself, can you still call them a victim? You also throw blame around like a blanket...but you're missing a large part of the target. That is the actual "victims" themselves.

Let me tell you, it is not the President's fault that these folks are in this predicament. It's not the fault of our governor. It's not the fault of the state police, or any of the local authorities. It is their fault. They were warned to get out. They were given a means to get to safety (yes shelters were provided ... no one was turned away) and they refused.

Now you, in Conneticut I believe, are gonna sit there and say that it is someone else's fault for their predicament? C'mon.

Hell, the man that I saw yesterday is still in harms way. Should we send a police unit over there to put him in cuffs and take him to Baton Rouge and set him free? Those police units are kinda busy guarding downed power lines that are sparking so that no one get's themselves electrecuted. Those police units are busy trying to stop those "victims" from killing their rescuers and from stealing electrical appliances (and putting themselves in harms way while they're doing it). Hell, when do we stop protecting these victims from themselves and use our resources to get on with the process of getting this city inhabitable so that all of those displaced folks can get back home. Right now, today, the police are gonna be real busy letting in the citizens so that they can go assess the damage to their homes, and get what they can salvage out. The authorities are needed to keep the order for that. Why should they have to divide their resources to go protect these victims from themselves.

Nuff said.

Halfdeck
2005-09-05, 12:02 PM
From seeing 20 people watch the same event and tell you 20 different opinions on what they saw, saying "this is how it really is" is as accurate as any media coverage out there. "This is how I and my friends see it down in Louisiana" is more like it.

People blaming George Bush for this is just unfounded, and the media coverage may be over dramatized for the sake of ratings, but you know what? I'm glad the media is comparing this to 9/11, the tsunami disaster and whatever else. If that type of inaccurate coverage keep people in line and speed things up and save a few extra lives, I'm all for it.

Most people around here know that those folks that are dead or stranded did it to themselves. We feel sorry for them, to an extent. Alot of folks around here also feel that these people are keeping the authorities from focusing on repairing the damage.

Honestly, my intial reaction after the hurricane hit FLA was this: "Dying in a hurricane has got to be the dumbest way to die."

But WTF, what is more important, saving lives or repairing the damage?

Blaming the victims only slows down the rescue effort. And frankly, blaming people for not leaving is as unproductive as blaming George Bush for changes in the weather.

We can blame whoever later but right now, I don't care if people are shooting at choppers and flipping over rescue boats. There are people dying/suffering out there and that has got to stop.

CaptainJSparrow
2005-09-05, 12:09 PM
Halfdeck...you are right "This is how I and my friends see it down in Louisiana" is more like it." is a much more accurate way to say it.

It just get's my goat when folks try to place blame at the expense of people that are trying to help. In this instance, the fed & local governments are helping.

The dieing and suffering will stop and everything is being done by the authorities to do that. No one is perfect, they will make mistakes, but I'm proud of the efforts that I've seen, both on the news and firsthand.

SirMoby
2005-09-05, 12:53 PM
Captain, your compassion and IQ are showing.

Torn Rose
2005-09-05, 01:15 PM
"The Buck stops here" is something Bush will never say.

Blame all of those who are simply too poor to own a car or for not having the physical ability to walk to the superdome or where ever, let’s also blame them for having no authority in place at the superdome and other places and also blame them for not having FEMA in the city for the first 5 days while CNN and other news stations where there the entire time asking over and over where is FEMA?

I think the NO mayor needs to be thrown in jail for all his lies since he is the one on tv telling those of us who do not live in Louisiana that it is fucked beyond belief and that people are dying, I feel stupid for listening to this person, I mean really, what does he know? Is he there? Odds are he is letting CNN making his decisions.

Thank you for setting me straight, when the USA can get a water purifier to Sri Lanka in 18 hours after a tsunami but it takes 5 days for FEMA to get to a major US city I just thought that was wrong, but since the people who are "there" say other wise, I must be wrong.

Lemmy when you call for a refund, tell them we want our donations back as well.

BTW, someone said FEMA did such a great job here in Florida, I suggest you come to Florida and talk to the people who are still waiting for FEMA to do their jobs and to the ones who are now being kicked out of the trailers FEMA brought in for them to live in until their homes are rebuilt which in most cases their old home is still there waiting on FEMA to do their job and let them start rebuilding.

Yes, it is for sure the so called “victims” faults that FEMA is ran by someone incompetent to do that job, and since that person was appointed by Bush, it must all be Clintons fault since he got a blowjob.

CaptainJSparrow
2005-09-05, 01:49 PM
Hey, while we're blaming them for everything let's blame them for the hurricane as well. I'm sure you can find someone to point fingers at that that nasty old hurricane actually was allowed to hit Louisiana.

It's the President's fault. The governor's? Maybe it's the mayor's fault.

You guy's crack me up. Gotta bitch about something, huh?

Mistakes were made. Good things were done too though. Next time, we'll be better prepared, but I'd imagine, mistakes will still be made.

SirMoby, I've done alot to help others around here. What have you done? Please don't talk to me about compassion when you sit there and just bitch. Oh, and my IQ is 165...what is yours?

Lemmy
2005-09-05, 02:07 PM
You also throw blame around like a blanket...Captain, I don't think I mentioned blame at all. It was simply what I perceived to be your lack of compassion that prompted my post. But now that you mention it...

At the end of the day, the buck does stop with the President. I'm not saying that he personally should be held responsible for every little fuckup in FEMA, the military or the National Guard, but when it became apparent early on that things were going FUBAR he didn't show any kind of leadership. Commander in Chief isn't an honorary title. He has the power to take control. He didn't.

On a side note, for the Katrina fuckup and too many other reasons to list here, I personally think GWB should be put in front of a firing squad. I believe they're still allowed to execute retards in Texas.

Now you, in Conneticut I believe, are gonna sit there and say that it is someone else's fault for their predicament?I really don't see what my state of residence has to do with anything.

Bill
2005-09-05, 03:43 PM
Now I think I feel kinda dumb for having donated money.

Next time I'll know better.

Chop Smith
2005-09-05, 04:13 PM
Gen Russell Honore just told a Louisiana Congressman and a news reporter that they were full of bull shit. Basically, "if you are not on the streets of New Orleans" shut the fuck up and do something. I don't know who appointed him to be in charge, but they made a good choice - native of Louisiana and daughters live in New Orleans. This is a link to his CNN profile http://www.cnn.com/2005/US/09/02/honore.profile/

RawAlex
2005-09-05, 04:27 PM
I just saw a report on CNN, Ex presidents Bush (father) and Clinton touring and setting up a fund that will 100% pass money directly to the states involved.

They interviewed Clinton... his off the cuff remarks about responsiblity, FEMA, Homeland Security, energy policy, action, ideas, and policies were so bang on. I remember now how this guy became president, by being able to say what so many of us think. Most important, he said "all of this is for the future, 60, 90 120, days... whatever... what is important now is taking care of what is here now".

It's not about political party - it is about appearing to take charge. Bush doesn't look like a man at the wheel, more like a passenger. The buck stops somewhere else, but he really isn't sure where (but he'll ask Cheney in case he knows - when he gets back from vacation).

"Don't just stand there Dr Dre, OPERATE"!

RawAlex
2005-09-05, 04:28 PM
Now I think I feel kinda dumb for having donated money.

Next time I'll know better.

I am starting to get the same feeling... which is sad.

Jim
2005-09-05, 04:40 PM
I have actually been able to stay away from news stations for the past few days. I feel good about my children's and my donations. Living in NYS, there really is nothing more I can do than give money. I do hope it goes to the right place.

If I were closer, I would do as much as I possibly could. When the twin towers went down, my wife and 2 boys jumped in my truck and followed the fire trucks down the thruway. We were stopped from entering the city but again, we did make quite a large donation. And at that time, we really couldn't afford it.

I do blame the government for not getting people out faster. I do blame the government for not getting supplies faster. Taking care of our people during and after a disaster is the government's responsibility. And they let everyone down....again.

Tubey
2005-09-05, 05:18 PM
I am waiting on blaming anyone, there are too many variables. Besides they didn't know where the storm was going exactly, they had it going over NO then it went to the east some models were even predicting it to west of NO. So the question of where to put supplies and how much was unpredictable. Who knows they may have had a wharehouse full in NO and someone lost the keys.
In short, I find fault with everyone, from the govt to the people who refused to leave, and it becomes a big circle of what if. People have to realize errors happen and to have a perfect plan will never happen in a disaster this large.
So I wait, try to figure out what went wrong and try to prevent it from happening again. To sit here and get worked up about it now won't change what happened, it just adds more frustration and divides the effort to fix the problem at hand. As one person once said "hind sight is 20/20."

RawAlex
2005-09-05, 06:14 PM
I am waiting on blaming anyone, there are too many variables. Besides they didn't know where the storm was going exactly, they had it going over NO then it went to the east some models were even predicting it to west of NO. So the question of where to put supplies and how much was unpredictable. Who knows they may have had a wharehouse full in NO and someone lost the keys.
In short, I find fault with everyone, from the govt to the people who refused to leave, and it becomes a big circle of what if. People have to realize errors happen and to have a perfect plan will never happen in a disaster this large.
So I wait, try to figure out what went wrong and try to prevent it from happening again. To sit here and get worked up about it now won't change what happened, it just adds more frustration and divides the effort to fix the problem at hand. As one person once said "hind sight is 20/20."


Tubey, no matter which way the storm goes, the people should have been ready - the military should have been on alert, the first round of supplies should have been in the trucks, and the fema people should have been ready to go.

It shouldn't have taken until Wednesday or Thursday to get these people on the ground.

SOMEONE dropped the ball - and the buck stops with the guy in the oval office (actually, he was the guy in a ranch in Texas taking a vacation until 2 days after the storm hit).

They still don't have a grip - why they have not ordered an evacuation of New Orleans is beyond me. they are still "just asking".

The head and the chicken have long since been seperated.

docholly
2005-09-05, 10:58 PM
Now I think I feel kinda dumb for having donated money.

Next time I'll know better.

If you gave it with an honest heart, no need to feel bad at all. We are each responsible for our own actions as well as those who are unable, for whatever the reason, help themselves.

Bill
2005-09-06, 12:02 AM
Well, I was exaggerating momentary feelings of queasiness. I don't really feel that way.

I think I was trying to say something about how this situation is so extreme, and the political spinning and illusion-making on all sides is so extreme, that it's impossible to know how to feel about it.

Can't trust the media.

Can't trust the government.

FEMA wants me to give money to Operation Blessing and Second Harvest.

The reports of gunfire at helicopters are shown to be lies. The reports that Gov. Blanco didn't "file the proper paperwork", which filled the media, are shown to be lies. Someone created and coldly used those lies.

And the implications of what CaptainJ appears to be saying are depressing.

It's a crazy, ugly, sad situation. In situations like this, who knows if it's right to give money, and if the money you give will be used properly?

docholly
2005-09-06, 12:47 AM
Well, I was exaggerating momentary feelings of queasiness. I don't really feel that way.



well actually when i first read that response i was like surely he is being sarcastic.. then when RA weighed in, i was like hmmm i must be having a "old-timers" moment and just not getting it..


Can't trust the media.

Can't trust the government.

FEMA wants me to give money to Operation Blessing and Second Harvest.

The reports of gunfire at helicopters are shown to be lies. The reports that Gov. Blanco didn't "file the proper paperwork", which filled the media, are shown to be lies. Someone created and coldly used those lies.

And the implications of what CaptainJ appears to be saying are depressing.



I would consider the source of the information as well. Even eye witness accounts can differ depending on whose eyes are doing the viewing.

RawAlex
2005-09-06, 01:02 AM
docholly, I wain't kidding... I don't feel great. Thankfully I gave money to the Red Cross rather than to any other organization, they seem to be have been first on the scene (even losing some of the vehicles to flooding... FEMA can't even suggest to claim that).

There is some very serious concern that someone important dropped the ball, and already the signs of coverup and misdirection are in the air. I feel truly sorry for those people caught in the middle - the people of Mississippi and Louisiana who are dealing with terrible conditions and horrific losses of both life and property.

The smell is travelling very far indeed.

CaptainJSparrow
2005-09-06, 01:20 AM
In the "for what it's worth category" I've seen alot of Red Cross folks in Baton Rouge, Sorrento, and New Orleans over the last 2 days.

Also, New Orleans police reported shooting and killing 4 persons who were firing at workers who were trying to plug the hole in the levee.

Local news that you guys may not be aware of:

-- Lt. General Russel Honore, who is overseeing the military effort in New Orleans, estimates about 10,000 people remain in the city. He says the city is not under siege, as has been reported.

-- Wireless carriers are returning service to the New Orleans area. Verizon Wireless said crews are working to restore service to New Orleans, Mandeville, Hammond, Covington and other cities. Cell phone service has been restored to the New Orleans airport, which is being used for evacuations.

-- The Murphy Oil complex in Meraux is leaking oil into a surrounding neighborhood. The leak was spotted in a flyover by the state Department of Environmental Quality.

-- Traffic was jammed in Jefferson Parish as residents returned to check on their homes and businesses. People started lining up in their cars in the night to get a head start into the parish. The parish permitted cars in at 6 a.m.

-- ExxonMobil, which was worried about supplies to its refinery in Baton Rouge, now is increasing production here. Energy experts fear an energy crisis will take an economic toll this winter because of production and refining disruptions combined with an expected harsh winter. ExxonMobil expects an increase in supply of oil from the Louisiana Offshore Oil Port, a critical facility that is used to offload oil from supertankers. The port in Venice was not damaged in the storm. ExxonMobil also says the U.S. Department of Energy has approved a request to borrow 6 million barrels of oil from the Strategic Petroleum Reserve

furrygirl
2005-09-06, 03:17 AM
A list of alternative places to donate funds: http://www.sparkplugfoundation.org/katrinarelief.html

Halfdeck
2005-09-06, 04:01 AM
I'm glad I donated to the Red Cross and I'm proud to know that many webmasters on this board also donated. It tells me unlike some people that were slow to respond in this disaster, webmasters here responded quickly and generously.

People believe what they want to believe and sometimes what we end up believing can be so far from the truth its scary.

I'm not down in NO nor was I with George Bush on Monday so I'm not going to pretend I know shit about what's going on just because I have access to a TV set and the internet.

CaptainJSparrow
2005-09-06, 01:38 PM
Hey, a buddy of mine is in the National Guard and he called and said that the military has shot 9 people so far for looting. He also said that the Army Rangers are in there now. Also, he walked Bourbon Street and said it doesn't even look like a hurricane came thru...said no water and it was clean!

CaptainJSparrow
2005-09-07, 11:17 PM
For anyone that is still interested, following is a copy of an article that a friend of mine sent to her e-mail list:

It has taken four long days for state and federal officials to figure

out how to deal with the disaster in New Orleans. I can't blame them,

because it has also taken me four long days to figure out what is going

on there. The reason is that the events there make no sense if you think

that we are confronting a natural disaster.

If this is just a natural disaster, the response for public officials is

obvious: you bring in food, water, and doctors; you send transportation

to evacuate refugees to temporary shelters; you send engineers to stop

the flooding and rebuild the city's infrastructure. For journalists,

natural disasters also have a familiar pattern: the heroism of ordinary

people pulling together to survive; the hard work and dedication of

doctors, nurses, and rescue workers; the steps being taken to clean up

and rebuild.

Public officials did not expect that the first thing they would have to

do is to send thousands of armed troops in armored vehicle, as if they

are suppressing an enemy insurgency. And journalists--myself

included--did not expect that the story would not be about rain, wind,

and flooding, but about rape, murder, and looting.

But this is not a natural disaster. It is a man-made disaster.

The man-made disaster is not an inadequate or incompetent response by

federal relief agencies, and it was not directly caused by Hurricane

Katrina. This is where just about every newspaper and television channel

has gotten the story wrong.

The man-made disaster we are now witnessing in New Orleans did not

happen over the past four days. It happened over the past four decades.

Hurricane Katrina merely exposed it to public view.

The man-made disaster is the welfare state.

For the past few days, I have found the news from New Orleans to be

confusing. People were not behaving as you would expect them to behave

in an emergency--indeed, they were not behaving as they have behaved in

other emergencies. That is what has shocked so many people: they have

been saying that this is not what we expect from America. In fact, it is

not even what we expect from a Third World country.

When confronted with a disaster, people usually rise to the occasion.

They work together to rescue people in danger, and they spontaneously

organize to keep order and solve problems. This is especially true in

America. We are an enterprising people, used to relying on our own

initiative rather than waiting around for the government to take care of

us. I have seen this a hundred times, in small examples (a small town

whose main traffic light had gone out, causing ordinary citizens to get

out of their cars and serve as impromptu traffic cops, directing cars

through the intersection) and large ones (the spontaneous response of

New Yorkers to September 11).

So what explains the chaos in New Orleans?

To give you an idea of the magnitude of what is going on, here is a

description from a <http://tinyurl.com/auyju> Washington Times story:

"Storm victims are raped and beaten; fights erupt with flying fists,

knives and guns; fires are breaking out; corpses litter the streets; and

police and rescue helicopters are repeatedly fired on.

"The plea from Mayor C. Ray Nagin came even as National Guardsmen poured

in to restore order and stop the looting, carjackings and gunfire....

"Last night, Gov. Kathleen Babineaux Blanco said 300 Iraq-hardened

Arkansas National Guard members were inside New Orleans with

shoot-to-kill orders.

"'These troops are...under my orders to restore order in the streets,'

she said. 'They have M-16s, and they are locked and loaded. These troops

know how to shoot and kill and they are more than willing to do so if

necessary and I expect they will.' "

The reference to Iraq is eerie. The photo that accompanies this article

shows National Guard troops, with rifles and armored vests, riding on an

armored vehicle through trash-strewn streets lined by a rabble of

squalid, listless people, one of whom appears to be yelling at them. It

looks exactly like a scene from Sadr City in Baghdad.

What explains bands of thugs using a natural disaster as an excuse for

an orgy of looting, armed robbery, and rape? What causes unruly mobs to

storm the very buses that have arrived to evacuate them, causing the

drivers to drive away, frightened for their lives? What causes people to

attack the doctors trying to treat patients at the Super Dome?

Why are people responding to natural destruction by causing further

destruction? Why are they attacking the people who are trying to help

them?

My wife, Sherri, figured it out first, and she figured it out on a

sense-of-life level. While watching the coverage last night on Fox News

Channel, she told me that she was getting a familiar feeling. She

studied architecture at the Illinois Institute of Chicago, which is

located in the South Side of Chicago just blocks away from the Robert

Taylor Homes, one of the largest high-rise public housing projects in

America. "The projects," as they were known, were infamous for

uncontrollable crime and irremediable squalor. (They have since,

mercifully, been <http://tinyurl.com/9hu4u>

demolished.)

What Sherri was getting from last night's television coverage was a

whiff of the sense of life of "the projects." Then the "crawl"--the

informational phrases flashed at the bottom of the screen on most news

channels--gave some vital statistics to confirm this sense: 75% of the

residents of New Orleans had already evacuated before the hurricane, and

of the 300,000 or so who remained, a large number were from the city's

public housing projects. Jack Wakeland then gave me an additional,

crucial fact: early reports from CNN and Fox indicated that the city had

no plan for evacuating all of the prisoners in the city's jails--so they

just let many of them loose. There is no doubt a significant overlap

between these two populations--that is, a large number of people in the

jails used to live in the housing projects, and vice versa.

There were many decent, innocent people trapped in New Orleans when the

deluge hit--but they were trapped alongside large numbers of people from

two

groups: criminals--and wards of the welfare state, people selected, over

decades, for their lack of initiative and self-induced helplessness. The

welfare wards were a mass of sheep--on whom the incompetent

administration of New Orleans unleashed a pack of wolves.

All of this is related, incidentally, to the apparent incompetence of

the city government, which failed to plan for a total evacuation of the

city, despite the knowledge that this might be necessary. But in a city

corrupted by the welfare state, the job of city officials is to ensure

the flow of handouts to welfare recipients and patronage to political

supporters--not to ensure a lawful, orderly evacuation in case of

emergency.

No one has really reported this story, as far as I can tell. In fact,

some are already actively distorting it, blaming President Bush, for

example, for failing to personally ensure that the Mayor of New Orleans

had drafted an adequate evacuation plan. The worst example is an

execrable piece from the <http://tinyurl.com/ah5j7> Toronto Globe and

Mail, by a supercilious Canadian who blames the chaos on American

"individualism." But the truth is precisely the opposite: the chaos was

caused by a system that was the exact opposite of individualism.

What Hurricane Katrina exposed was the psychological consequences of the

welfare state. What we consider "normal" behavior in an emergency is

behavior that is normal for people who have values and take the

responsibility to pursue and protect them. People with values respond to

a disaster by fighting against it and doing whatever it takes to

overcome the difficulties they face. They don't sit around and complain

that the government hasn't taken care of them. They don't use the chaos

of a disaster as an opportunity to prey on their fellow men.

But what about criminals and welfare parasites? Do they worry about

saving their houses and property? They don't, because they don't own

anything. Do they worry about what is going to happen to their

businesses or how they are going to make a living? They never worried

about those things before. Do they worry about crime and looting? But

living off of stolen wealth is a way of life for them.

The welfare state--and the brutish, uncivilized mentality it sustains

and encourages--is the man-made disaster that explains the moral

ugliness that has swamped New Orleans. And that is the story that no one

is reporting.

Bill
2005-09-07, 11:39 PM
You do know that most of the news agencies are now saying the stories of armed gangs, rapes, and shooting at rescuers have been proven to be false, or at best, unsupported?

I've been looking for hard, confirmed evidence of crimes like these. So far, there has been almost nothing.

There has been suggestions that these stories were invented, I gather the prime suspect is FEMA and "anonymous senior officials" to justify their inaction.

Has anyone seen hard news stories confirming "Road Warrior" type shit?

Halfdeck
2005-09-08, 12:01 AM
Nice article Captain.

Lemmy
2005-09-08, 12:22 AM
The problem isn't with the welfare state, because America isn't one. Among all the countries in Western civilization that we like to compare us with America is the one that cares least about the welfare of the individual.

I suspect most of us would have acted like animals after a while if left to our own devices in a disaster stricken city. It's a typical American response to "shoot to kill" rather than address the cause of the problem. It's also probably cheaper in the short term and has the added benefit of thinning out the population of stupid, incompetent, lazy, drunken fucks in the public housing projects. It's a win-win situation.

Here's my response to that: Fuck the governor of Louisiana, who, from her dry safety in Baton Rouge, advocates a shoot to kill policy against people with no other means who help themselves to baby formula, bread and soda in an effort to stay alive.

Anyone who still denies incompetence at local, regional and national levels in connection with Katrina really hasn't been paying attention. Or they're just plain dumb.

The same goes for anyone who doesn't see the connection here with the racial divide America still is struggling with some 140 years after slavery was abolished. Imagine had this happened in Boston MA or Westchester County, NY. But it happened in NOLA, a city with 60% mostly poor, dumb, black crack heads. I'm beginning to see where Neil Young got his inspiration from.

furrygirl
2005-09-08, 02:16 AM
Besides the same old, "Do we blame those poor black crackheads, or do we blame the rich white cokehead running the country?" debate, does any have any leads for groups that are taking on-the-ground volunteers WITHOUT medical training?

I've been looking for days, and I can not find a group who does human or animal rescues in flooded areas that accept non-professionals. Seriously, do really I need a degree to be able to round up stray dogs or pass out blankets? It's incredibly frustrating that with the current bottle-necking of resources coming in to the area, everyone wants money, but not personel. I don't drive or own a car, I don't have a boat, I don't live in the south, but surely there's some sort of formal project that needs actual physical help.

Linkster
2005-09-08, 07:22 AM
furry girl
http://www.aspca.org/site/PageServer?pagename=hurricane_volunteer
although no one is gonna allow someone to enter the city to rescue animals without training right now - there are plenty of volunteer jobs available in the area - someone needs to care for these animals as they are brought in and for someone that hasnt been trained in the handling of possible rabid, contaminated animals, it would be suicide to try the rescue phase - but the shelters are begging for volunteers to take care of the animals

Linkster
2005-09-08, 07:37 AM
The problem isn't with the welfare state, because America isn't one. .

Lemmy - the problem is that (having lived there and going back constantly) New Orleans is a welfare state - true the rest of the country is not on average but there are pockets in Wash DC, Chicago, etc - and I think the point here is that what was left after the initial call for evacuation was a complete welfare state.
The interesting comment I heard yesterday - and most people have missed this - the murder/rape/injury rate in New Orleans that youve been hearing about (possibly blown out of proportion for news casts but thats another topic) is way lower than the normal rate for that city - all the tourists and cabbies are gone so they dont have anyone to kill.
The gang related violence is a hidden, but definitely a huge part of New Orleans - it doesnt get a lot of publicity - they would lose the convention and tourism trade if it was publicized.
Most of the people that are causing the problems that are being reported are the gangs that dont want to lose their "turf" and are protecting it - the police units know who they are - and are trying to deal with them - but its tough when you still have a quarter of the police force out of communication (not their fault - its a command and control issue with the mayor) and still holing up in certain parts of the city as separate "police forces" that are slowly being brought back into the response organization - its just a matter of getting them the comms and directing the separate "precincts" into one force.

I also disagree that it has anything whatsoever to do with race - its class - and that is something the city just did not plan for - no matter what the politics and news spinners spew - it is just a logistical fact that the class of people that are still there are not people with the means to get themselves out of the city - and every city in this country has the same problem - they dont have a plan to evacuated "everyone" - they depend on personal vehicles for most of it.
The only difference in this case against other cities is that New Orleans is actually a smaller city and we are just lucky this was not a city like NYC where we would be facing hundreds of thousands of deaths - something to think about.

furrygirl
2005-09-08, 07:37 AM
Thanks for the link, I've already emailed every animal group in the area, although HSUS and the ASPCA seem to be the only ones at the timewho are being allowed into disafter areas. No one's gotten back to me yet, and as far as I can tell from message boards, there simply are no openings for non-pros in animal or human aid.

If I lived down there, I'd be happy to open my yard to a bunch of dogs, but as a non-driver, trying to get dehydrated, hungry, sick, possibly injured animals to my home in Seattle would be too much of a headache.

I've actually gotten quite a biting from a (possibly rabid) stray cat before and been through rabies treatments, so it is a risk I'm truly aware of the pain of. I've known a few people who have done animal rescues in SoCal after major fires, and it's pretty much being scratched to hell, fighting with scared, injured animals who have found themselves their own safe place and don't want anyone touching them. It's not a fun vacation, and it's not about snuggling with cuddly wuddly puppies and kittens. Animals, like humans, tend to go a bit feral when left to completely fend for themselves.

CaptainJSparrow
2005-09-08, 11:03 AM
Linkster....what you said. You hit the nail on the head.

It's too bad that you folks can only watch the national news where each station is striving hard to scream "the sky is falling" the loudest and with the most emphasis on each and every word. We have a local station that is much more unbiased. We're seeing pictures from New Orleans that are filmed by locals. We're hearing stories from folks that we know that are in New Orleans right now, who are calling us, and telling us what is actually going on.

None of the authorities are shooting folks looting for food and water. There are stores in New Orleans, Walmart is one of them, that opened their doors and are giving away food and bottled water.

Nah, the looters that the authorities are ordered to shoot are the ones that are trying to take advantage of the situation. The ones that are stealing electronics and other valuables. The people that don't want to leave because, for them, it is a huge oportunity to steal.

My ex-wife's cousin stayed throughout the storm in Metarie, but left 2 days ago because she saw looters every night breaking into homes around her.

Bill
2005-09-08, 03:46 PM
Well, I've been looking for news reports to confirm that there was murder, armed gangs, rampaging and rapes. So far nothing, but the day is young.

I did find this first hand report by two EMS folks who were trapped in a hotel by Katrina.

I think we all heard the story about how this group pooled money to hire a bus convoy to take them out of the city, but that the national guard stopped the busses and commandeered them for some unknown (to the news sources) use.

Well, this same group had a hard time, spending four days trapped inside the city.

http://www.emsnetwork.org/artman/publish/article_18337.shtml

Here's a bit from the article:

"From a woman with a battery powered radio we learned that the media was talking about us. Up in full view on the freeway, every relief and news organizations saw us on their way into the City. Officials were being asked what they were going to do about all those families living up on the freeway? The officials responded they were going to take care of us. Some of us got a sinking feeling. "Taking care of us" had an ominous tone to it.

Unfortunately, our sinking feeling (along with the sinking City) was correct. Just as dusk set in, a Gretna Sheriff showed up, jumped out of his patrol vehicle, aimed his gun at our faces, screaming, "Get off the fucking freeway". A helicopter arrived and used the wind from its blades to blow away our flimsy structures. As we retreated, the sheriff loaded up his truck with our food and water.

Once again, at gunpoint, we were forced off the freeway. All the law enforcement agencies appeared threatened when we congregated or congealed into groups of 20 or more. In every congregation of "victims" they saw "mob" or "riot". We felt safety in numbers. Our "we must stay together" was impossible because the agencies would force us into small atomized groups."

So - the authorities apparently _STOLE_ this groups food and water to force them out of the public eye.

CaptainJSparrow
2005-09-08, 04:15 PM
On the local news, the New Orleans police chief just confirmed that his officers were shot at from the Superdome.

Also, the news confirmed that locals are throwing rocks at the National Guardsmen.

Gotta tell ya...the more I hear, I'm kinda embarrassed about our governor. I hear that the President gave her two options, and she told him she needed 24 hours to think about it. Apparently, she is having problems making decisions.

Bill
2005-09-08, 04:28 PM
Well, here is a reference to a "shoot out".

The only shoot out that I've seen clearly mentioned on the TV news was an incident where supposedly armed men "on a briedge" fired at rescue workers, and the police fired back. The first report was the 5 locals had been killed, that was later revised to 2 killed, two wounded, and others missing.

One version of this I heard in a blog was that the men who were killed were not firing _at_ rescue workers, they were firing in the air to attract the attention of rescue workers. The police then fired on them. Not sure if this is true, but it does match some television reports I've seen, in which Nawliners were complaining that they were shot at after firing guns to attract help.

I'm not sure if this is the same incident:

From Reporters Sans Frontiers

http://www.rsf.org/article.php3?id_article=14894

Police violence against journalists in New Orleans in Katrina aftermath

"A second incident involved Gordon Russell of the New Orleans-based Times-Picayune daily as he was covering a shoot-out between police and local residents near the convention centre where hurricane victims were awaiting evacuation. The police detained Russell and smashed all of his equipment on the ground. Russell was forced to flee to avoid further violence and reportedly left the city the same day."

Bill
2005-09-08, 04:41 PM
Does the local channel you are watching have a website Jeff?

As far as I'm concerned, Louisiana can shoot or imprision anybody they want to. It's not my state, and not my city. I don't live in the city. I assumed all cities have a hard core of poor and lower class people who commit most of the casual crime.

I'm just interested in the facts.

Linkster
2005-09-08, 06:41 PM
Bill - nola.com has about the best news that seems to be accurate - they are the website of the Times-Picuyane (the NO newspaper) - there is also a small blog being run by the guys at DirecNic downtown at mgno.com - kinda isolated but they do have a birds eye view of the business district

Bill
2005-09-08, 07:03 PM
Gotta tell ya...the more I hear, I'm kinda embarrassed about our governor. I hear that the President gave her two options, and she told him she needed 24 hours to think about it. Apparently, she is having problems making decisions.

You have heard her explantion, haven't you? She says that the president wanted her to hand over all authority for the area, possibly for the whole state. to the federal government, and I believe allow them to declare martial law.

She says she didn't believe it was in the best interests of the State of Louisiana to hand over the state to the federal government, and that she didn't want martial law to be declared.

There apparantly is a lot of backstory - about her thinking this was a CYA move by the pres, who could then ride in as a conquering hero and blame the state entirely for the delay.

There are two sides to every story.

Linkster
2005-09-08, 07:52 PM
First off - lets get something straight as there has been a lot of misuse of terms here:
Martial Law isnt something a local government can request - it can be done by the president or recommended by his local area commander -
http://www.washingtonwatchdog.org/documents/cfr/title32/part501.html#501.4

Secondly - the military cannot act as law enforcement by law in the US - unless congress specifically authorizes it under the Posse Comitatus Act:
http://www.nwc.navy.mil/library/3Publications/NWCLibraryPublications/LibNotes/libpossecom.htm

That said - A declaration of a "state of emergency" was made by the Governer prior to the hurricane coming ashore - that gave the President power to mobilize FEMA and the Coast Guard to assist locals

The real issue here is that the civilian population of this country thinks that the all mighty US government can just march in and do what it needs to do to help - by law it is specifically prohibited from doing just that - we fucking fought a civil war 150 years ago because of those laws - to prevent the government from telling states how to run their business - I know everybody thinks the issue was slavery - it wasnt - read the real history sometime.

I hate that sometimes we think that they should help out and they have even overstepped their bounds in many cases (like Fla hurricanes) - but those cases all used Natl Guard - which in this case took a few days to mobilize since there werent any available except for the soldiers in Miss - who were a little busy with their own problems

Bill
2005-09-08, 09:37 PM
I'm not sure I'm understanding your point, Linkster.

Would you elaborate?

I'm willing to stipulate that the Governor and the Mayor were incompetent. It's fine with me if Louisianans want to string them up. A people gets the government it deserves.

But, this storyline of the Governor blocking the Presidents offer of help has been talked about quite a bit, and as I said, there is supposedly more to the story than the damning headlines rolling across the screen two to four days ago.

If you want to blame Lousianans, the Louisiana Democrats, and the local responders, that's fine with me.

If you think FEMA and the Bush administration did a fine job, well, I think you are bug fucking nuts, and I'm wondering what the fuck you saw in person that wasn't on my TV screen.

Bill
2005-09-08, 09:53 PM
Here is the Washington Post article that was the original source to the blogosphere discussions:

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/09/03/AR2005090301680.html

Note the source of my statement about "martial law". I knew that there was a concern about declaring martial law that was part of the debate, altho I didn't remember the particulars clearly:

"Louisiana officials rejected the request after talks throughout the night, concerned that such a move would be comparable to a federal declaration of martial law."

This is the part of the article that is relevant to this issue:

"Behind the scenes, a power struggle emerged, as federal officials tried to wrest authority from Louisiana Gov. Kathleen Babineaux Blanco (D). Shortly before midnight Friday, the Bush administration sent her a proposed legal memorandum asking her to request a federal takeover of the evacuation of New Orleans, a source within the state's emergency operations center said Saturday.

The administration sought unified control over all local police and state National Guard units reporting to the governor. Louisiana officials rejected the request after talks throughout the night, concerned that such a move would be comparable to a federal declaration of martial law. Some officials in the state suspected a political motive behind the request. "Quite frankly, if they'd been able to pull off taking it away from the locals, they then could have blamed everything on the locals," said the source, who does not have the authority to speak publicly.

A senior administration official said that Bush has clear legal authority to federalize National Guard units to quell civil disturbances under the Insurrection Act and will continue to try to unify the chains of command that are split among the president, the Louisiana governor and the New Orleans mayor.

Louisiana did not reach out to a multi-state mutual aid compact for assistance until Wednesday, three state and federal officials said. As of Saturday, Blanco still had not declared a state of emergency, the senior Bush official said.

"The federal government stands ready to work with state and local officials to secure New Orleans and the state of Louisiana," White House spokesman Dan Bartlett said. "The president will not let any form of bureaucracy get in the way of protecting the citizens of Louisiana."

Blanco made two moves Saturday that protected her independence from the federal government: She created a philanthropic fund for the state's victims and hired James Lee Witt, Federal Emergency Management Agency director in the Clinton administration, to advise her on the relief effort."

Linkster
2005-09-08, 10:49 PM
First off Bill - that article has quite a few false statements in it - I guess the one that stands out is that the state of emergency wasnt declared "as of Saturday" - this is misinformation being promulgated through the Bush press aides - she did declare a state of emergency at 5 pm on Friday - the rest can also be disproven with actual statements that were put out on publicly broadcast tv statements in New Orleans.
This writer BTW is rewriting an article that came out on a blog written by a guy in Florida who made the whole thing up.

As far as the state not wanting aid - that is from what Im seeing not a correct statement either - according to news reports before the storm hit when asked, the governor stated she had not been in contact with the white house

Overall - I am trying to avoid most of the blame stuff because there is so much BS being put out (some even by reknowned journalists that arent checking their stories) and the spin machine is in full force int he white house obviously - since Bush is the one dropping in the polls by a long shot.
As far as local politics - the mayor issued a mandatory evacuation on Sunday morning - whether any large city could really evacuate all of its people in 24 hours is debatable - I tend to think its impossible - and anyone that thinks that it really could have been done any better with that timeframe should be in that position instead - but even if you had 1000 busses waiting, airplanes ready, troop transports standing by in the roads of New Orleans, the same people that didnt leave before still wouldnt have left - they DIDNT WANT TO! and still dont!


As far as your statement about FEMA and their response - that is a normal response from FEMA under the homeland security umbrella - that is why every former director of FEMA has said that the setup now is stupid - secondly - a lot of people are hammering the director for ineptness - which may be true - but its not his job to do immediate response - that responsibility is with the 6th district of FEMA located in Texas - and they did respond per their plan - as did numerous other governmental agencies (ie FBI, ATF etc who were in the city as soon as the storm was over) - but they were doing what they are supposed to do per their plans - which is to protect government interests in the city ONLY! That is the fault associated with the new Homeland security department - it places all of the initial "disaster recovery" on local fire depts, police and sheriff depts - the amount of money they were given to prepare for response was incredible - of course most departments just bought new command busses, coffee dispensers etc. FEMA also provided locals with money to train for these type of disasters, as FEMA was transferring the "job"

I hope you understand that I dont like what I see - but being my age and having been through riots, bombings and other amazing things I saw as a teen (like seeing Washington DC on fire) - and watching the transfer of power under the homeland security department and knowing what would happen with an additional layer of red tape - I fully expected this to happen - just didnt think it would happen so close to home :)

Linkster
2005-09-08, 10:54 PM
BTW Bill - having been to so many Mardi Gras events - in the back of my mind I still have spinning this feeling of something just not being kosher - this police dept and the local sheriffs, hwy patrol etc, every year, can control 1.5 million drunks partying, killing each other raping, looting, you name it - and do one fantastic job of it with never a complaint or issue - and yet a little storm that blows some water into the city comes along and they go ballistic? Something smells

Linkster
2005-09-08, 10:58 PM
OK - one more little post LOL
Here is what Region 6 of FEMA did on AUG 30 - which is exactly by the book and exactly the way FEMA is set up now:
http://www.fema.gov/news/regionnews.fema?region=6

CaptainJSparrow
2005-09-08, 11:56 PM
Hey Bill, that local TV station's website is at:

http://wafb.com/

You know, I'm not much into politics as I stated earlier. My guess is that the governor is incompetant and that she didn't want to give up power to the federal government because she thought that she'd never win another election if she did. Unfortunately for her, she probably won't anyway.

Having 1 central authority that controls all of the forces that you mentioned earlier is probably a good idea. Too many chiefs usually means that there is alot of arguing and not enough results. That said the federal government is such a behemoth that it would be amazing if they truly accomplished anything any faster than what is currently being accomplished.

I still say that our contra-flow worked exceptionally well and that the majority of people that wanted to get out, got out.

We'll know more about the shootings and looting over the next week or so. I will keep ya'll informed when I hear things that are confirmed...such as when my friends in the reserves or police departments tell me things that they've seen first hand.

Good night all.

furrygirl
2005-09-09, 06:05 AM
BTW Bill - having been to so many Mardi Gras events - in the back of my mind I still have spinning this feeling of something just not being kosher - this police dept and the local sheriffs, hwy patrol etc, every year, can control 1.5 million drunks partying, killing each other raping, looting, you name it - and do one fantastic job of it with never a complaint or issue - and yet a little storm that blows some water into the city comes along and they go ballistic? Something smells
Wait, are you saying that you are skeptical of reports of police misbehavior because they never had many problems you could see during Mardi Gras?

The big difference between the two being that one is a bunch of better-off partiers, one is a bunch of poor, starving, sick people who were left to die. I'm not saying that shooting at rescuers helps anyone, but I do completely understand where people are coming from with the anger and frustration.

Plus, are there any real, confirmed reports of this mass raping and cop-shooting I keep hearing rumors of?


And, on another note, I'm still looking to find someone down there accepting volunteers. And new leads from anyone? I'm thinking of just flying down there with a backback full of Clif Bars and bug spray and seeing what I can do.

Linkster
2005-09-09, 07:19 AM
Wait, are you saying that you are skeptical of reports of police misbehavior because they never had many problems you could see during Mardi Gras?

The big difference between the two being that one is a bunch of better-off partiers, one is a bunch of poor, starving, sick people who were left to die. I'm not saying that shooting at rescuers helps anyone, but I do completely understand where people are coming from with the anger and frustration.

Plus, are there any real, confirmed reports of this mass raping and cop-shooting I keep hearing rumors of?


I dont think I was trying to say I was skeptical about the police mis-behaviour, more I think I am concerned with the second part - that so far there hasnt been one confirmed report of the shootings and rapes - other than a few heresay reports that the media keeps blowing up - and unfortunately seems to dominate the news instead of reporters doing their job and getting facts (something that they seem to have forgotton over the years)

I tend to believe that there is still a group of old gang members that have run several neighborhoods for some time, that are still there trying to salvage their turf - and may be taking potshots at cops. It just amazes me though that the media has twisted so many stories - the one I keep thinking about is the "police turn into looters and ransack Walmart" story. Here is a whole precinct of cops that have lost their headquarters, have no communication with the chief of police, see looters robbing walmart, shoo them away, and set up their HQ in Walmart - the news media reports it as police looting - but when you talk to the captain of that precinct he is pretty adamant that he was just trying to find a dry place to he could group his cops into one place and set up a central dry location. Just one example of the news media taking a story from an evacuee and turning it into fact - fortunately one news group actually went out to the Walmart and interviewed the captain of police and he basically told the reporter to F*** off when asked about his cops being looters.

Linkster
2005-09-09, 07:26 AM
one is a bunch of poor, starving, sick people who were left to die. I'm not saying that shooting at rescuers helps anyone, but I do completely understand where people are coming from with the anger and frustration..
No one down there was "left to die" - the days before the storm came in the police were driving through every neighborhood with loudspeakers telling people to get out and where they could get busses - and to use the superdome as a last resort shelter. Having lived (temporarily) in one of the poorest neighborhoods down there I can tell you that everyone has a TV and would have seen the mayor and governor two days before the storm telling them to get out, and the only anger they have is when the cops try to help them - Im not totally heartless - I just know that 99% of the people that wouldnt leave are the ones that are still there refusing to leave and hiding out in the projects.

As far as wanting to help out I know the Red Cross is still taking volunteers - they train you for an hour and then put you out there helping people - although I dont think flying in would be a viable option yet :)

Kinky
2005-09-09, 09:04 AM
It just amazes me though that the media has twisted so many stories - the one I keep thinking about is the "police turn into looters and ransack Walmart" story. Here is a whole precinct of cops that have lost their headquarters, have no communication with the chief of police, see looters robbing walmart, shoo them away, and set up their HQ in Walmart - the news media reports it as police looting - but when you talk to the captain of that precinct he is pretty adamant that he was just trying to find a dry place to he could group his cops into one place and set up a central dry location. Just one example of the news media taking a story from an evacuee and turning it into fact - fortunately one news group actually went out to the Walmart and interviewed the captain of police and he basically told the reporter to F*** off when asked about his cops being looters.
some police were looting

HERE IS THE VIDEO (http://www.flurl.com/featured_entry.php?action=view_entry&id=16)

Lemmy
2005-09-09, 09:30 AM
some police were looting

HERE IS THE VIDEO (http://www.flurl.com/featured_entry.php?action=view_entry&id=16)
That's hilarious...and disturbing.

Cleo
2005-09-09, 09:38 AM
God Outdoes Terrorists Yet Again
http://www.theonion.com/content/node/40305/

docholly
2005-09-09, 09:43 AM
With all due respect Linkster, one thing i do have to take exception to is this:

No one down there was "left to die"

I think at least 30 people would take exception to that:

At least 30 found in Nursing Home (http://www.sciencedaily.com/upi/?feed=TopNews&article=UPI-1-20050908-14070500-bc-us-katrina-nursinghome.xml)

..quite frankly who is to blame or what kind of shoes Condi was buying, or what bunker was Cheney hiding in, or what was done is trivial at this time.. those who think GWB did a GREAT job will continue to think so and try to 'blame' everyone else.. and those of us who think he's destroying 200+ years of democracy will just use this to bolster our position.

Let's just hope for the next 6-9 months we have no other disasters anywhere else in the country that require immediate action because it might take over 2-3 weeks just to find the National Guard.

Surfn
2005-09-09, 09:46 AM
some police were looting

HERE IS THE VIDEO (http://www.flurl.com/featured_entry.php?action=view_entry&id=16)
That is disturbing on so many levels :(

Dr Bizzaro
2005-09-09, 09:48 AM
Who said Bush cut his vacation 2 days short due to the Katrina?

Ramster
2005-09-09, 10:58 AM
Bush is embarrassing. :(

A great country being led by such a self centered idiot.

docholly
2005-09-09, 11:36 AM
Who said Bush cut his vacation 2 days short due to the Katrina?

something consistant about that elite club that includes Nero fiddling, Cake eating Marie Antoinette and George reading er fishing.. |cry|

Chop Smith
2005-09-09, 02:20 PM
Can ya'll solve the plight of the male plecia nearctica?

Linkster
2005-09-09, 06:17 PM
Chop - nahhh - youll just have to keep buying those nets for the front grill :)

As far as looting cops - looks like fun! - seems the guys that were doing it were allowing the other looters to do it as well?

DocHolly - I would guess there are exceptions to everything - and in that case I think the blame would be right on that nursing home staff - but dont get me wrong by my posts - I sure dont support Bush or even any part of the government - but I do think that a little reality needs to be interjected when the press is making up stories to rile up people. I seriously just watched the police chief of New Orleans with a bunch of his partners in FEMA and others announce that they would NOT be using force to evacuated anyone - and this was echoed by the city attorney.
Not 5 minutes later the news media was announcing that the New Orleans police and Natl Guard are using force to evacuate people at gunpoint - like I said - its the stories they make up to sensationalize this whole thing for ratings - and it sucks

Surfn
2005-09-09, 06:26 PM
...its the stories they make up to sensationalize this whole thing for ratings - and it sucks
It's all about the money. The more sensational they get the higher their ratings. The high their ratings the more they charge advertisers. An endless loop of greed at the top.

Theproofhouse
2005-09-09, 08:01 PM
Don't know about "stories made up"
But all reporting from tv stations around the world, has turned out to be accurate, and the truth.

Linkster
2005-09-09, 09:22 PM
Theproofhouse - Im assuming you are talking about what you are seeing in GB - which for some reason actually seems to be very accurate reporting at least on BBC - I think what you are missing is the local stations here and the cable news networks that are making up stories to increase their rankings in sensationalism - its a sad fact that we in the US have to sift through to find some semblence of truth :(

Bill
2005-09-09, 10:16 PM
I found a first person report that seems to confirm firing on helicopters. It's pretty critical of the police and the authorities, but it's an interesting read.

I have yet to find what I'm looking for, which is actual police reports, with evidence, of arrests made, or police shootings leading to known fatalities, or pictures of bulletholes in helicopters or police station walls.

This is where it's reprinted:

http://www.alternet.org/story/25220/

Some relevant clips:

"I know everyone has heard about people firing on helicopters. I'm certainly not saying it is right, but after being there, I understand. For five days, helicopters are flying overhead, but none of them are dropping water or food down for anyone. They fly by using load speakers saying that anyone found looting or stealing will be arrested, and those are the helicopters that are followed by gunshots, from what I see.

The only government group anyone has seen are the police with sawed-off shotguns threatening to arrest everyone who is walking around on the streets.

Everyone is fearful for his future, and fear leads people to do amazing, extraordinary things. It's a state of war. People don't even know who they're fighting, but they know they're at war. Twice, I bike away at full speed from people that come at me. Before I leave the city, my cash, backpack loaded with food and change of clothes and my camera are stolen. The final time, two people robbed me of my water. They didn't even ask for cash or my watch, just my water. It is desperation, and the last thing I could ever feel is anger."

"...They warn me about what neighborhoods to avoid, and that above everything else, it was critical to stay away from the police. They'll force you to leave by putting you on a bus destined for who knows where, and if you resist, they'll arrest you. It's the first time I sense that the police and government are seen as enemies by Katrina survivors. At first, I simply consider that shortsighted, but over the next two days, I start to understand why they think that way."

"The city is not at all empty as the news says it is. I find hundreds if not thousands of people in all the different neighborhoods, and they have no intention of leaving. First and foremost, they have nowhere to go. Many people don't want to leave. They don't trust they'll ever be let back in, and they certainly aren't going to allow their homes to be pillaged by people crafty enough not to get kicked out. Finally, they just don't believe the argument that the city will be unsafe and infested with disease.

They're armed and angry. They have already survived five straight days of no food and no water, and they don't believe those who haven't gotten them food or water are going to find a place for them to live."

Erick G
2005-09-09, 10:30 PM
CNN likes to show dead bodies alot.

Cleo
2005-09-09, 10:37 PM
The forcing people out of their homes I just don't understand.

I've been through hurricanes and remember well when Andrew destroyed Homestead Florida.

Last thing you want to do is leave your home. You want to protect what you have, take care of your animals, and try to start putting your life back together. Plus most of us don't have anyplace else to go.

These people's homes look dry and fine to live in yet they are forcing them out to go where?

This whole thing just makes no sense.

Kinky
2005-09-09, 10:58 PM
I have yet to find what I'm looking for, which is actual police reports, with evidence, of arrests made, or police shootings leading to known fatalities, or pictures of bulletholes in helicopters or police station walls.
I saw the NO deputy police chief in a live press conference stating that 2 people were killed by police and 4 others wounded

Police killed two people Sunday on the Danziger Bridge over the Industrial Canal, he said.

The incident began when a rescue worker heard gunshots and called police. When the responding unit saw six people on the bridge with guns, they called in a task force unit, which confronted the group, according to Riley.

"The subjects fired on the task force, which returned fire," he said, killing two on the scene and wounding two others. The other two fled and the task force pursued, wounding one and capturing the other.

All three of the wounded were hospitalized, Riley said.

HERE IS AN ARTICLE WITH THE FULL STORY (http://www.cnn.com/2005/US/09/05/katrina.new.orleans/)

Erick G
2005-09-09, 11:21 PM
Cleo they probably want to bulldoze the whole city. I wouldnt want to leave myself.
It makes no sense. I donated to the pet rescue fund.

Bill
2005-09-09, 11:33 PM
Yes, Kinky, that story is one of the few which appear to be confirmable, and I mentioned it in an earlier post in this thread.

But, it's not a _confirmed_ story. It's not a confirmed fatality. A confirmed fatality would include the names of the dead and wounded, where they were from, and ideally what weapons they were using and where the weapons came from.

If other looters are being shot, the police presumably have to bring the bodies back to some central spot for identification and storage. Leaving shot dead bodies around the city, and not reporting the killings, would be very strange.

If "gangs of armed men" are being arrested, they have to be being kept somewhere. If a cop has been shot, surely that has to have been entered into some official log somewhere.

If this is happening, sooner or later hard lists of names, places, dates will be released. Pictures of dead men. Pictures of bullet holes.

CaptainJSparrow
2005-09-09, 11:34 PM
Folks, we've seen police on local TV try to get people to leave and they won't. Haven't seen (on the local news) the police forcibly evacuate anyone.

Bill, I'm not sure that I believe that article that you posted. Nothing against you, but I think the author is lying.

Also, I know for a fact that the National Guard is down there. That article says "The only government group anyone has seen are the police with sawed-off shotguns threatening to arrest everyone who is walking around on the streets." This is just not true.

My friend that is down there called last night and said that the locals are throwing rocks and bottles of urine at them as they just walk by. His thought is that these people are the scum of the earth and most of his comrades in the military wish that they'd be allowed to open up on these lowlifes and put'em out of everybody's misery.

He also says that they've seen reports on CNN and the folks down there think those reports are mostly bullshit. This is straight from my buddy in the Guard unit in New Orleans.

Incidentally, I may talk with him tomorrow at some point. If anyone has any relevant questions, I'd be glad to ask him and post it here.

Bill
2005-09-09, 11:54 PM
Jeff, I'm pretty sure that article was written about a visit he made last weekend, so it's not current. He repeatedly mentions "5 days" since the hurricane, 5 days of no food no water.

It's been 12 days now I think.

I haven't been able to find first person reports more recent that describe the things I'm looking for.

One gets the impression things are much calmer now, but I can't tell if they truly are, or if this is just a media illusion.

That many people are still there, many more than thought, including many, many apparently very "straight" people, seems to be true, based on reports from the majot media tonight.

I feel bad for Baton Rouge. I hope that there will be long term benefits from this disaster for your city.

Bill
2005-09-10, 12:04 AM
My friend that is down there called last night and said that the locals are throwing rocks and bottles of urine at them as they just walk by. His thought is that these people are the scum of the earth and most of his comrades in the military wish that they'd be allowed to open up on these lowlifes and put'em out of everybody's misery.



An American soldier on an American street itching to pull the trigger on an American "lowlife" flinging a bottle of urine.

There is something archetypal about that.

An icon of possible futures.

CaptainJSparrow
2005-09-10, 12:24 AM
You know, these brave folks that are throwing urine at our soldiers...kinda reminds me of a kid hiding behind his mother's skirt as he sticks his tongue out at another kid.

Problem is, all of the authorities have alot to do down in New Orleans, and these people are hindering the progress.

They were told to get out. They were told that they would not be given any more food and water if they stayed. They were given a means to get out. If they choose to stay then let'em stay.

In a more perfect world, the authorities should totally ignore them and get to the business of making those areas inhabitable again. The authorities should only interact with them when they try to cause harm to others, hinder the progress of rebuilding, and when they are stealing things other than food and water.

Chop Smith
2005-09-10, 12:36 AM
When watching sensationalize TV, I find a bag of Zapp's and a bottle of Abita helps. Drink enough Abita and you can see whatever you want.

Captain, these brave folks that are throwing urine are the locals that the Creoles call Americans?

CaptainJSparrow
2005-09-10, 05:51 PM
Chop Smith,

Yep, they're Americans and Louisianians...they just don't represent the best of us. Matter of fact, they're more like the worst of us.

dareutwo
2005-09-14, 12:57 PM
Ok, got an email from my father this morning.
He is on his way down from Southern MN later today.
He is a retired EMT (ambulance personel)
Not sure how the hell they found him being retired, and he doesn't know when he'll be back. (3 week minumum) There is actually a whole plane of EMT's, Doctors, Nurses etc from the Rochester area (Mayo Clinic) on the way.
I told him to do whatever he could, but that he's about a week late.
He agreed, and said just "Take care of the cabin".
Though he did say that disease control was a top issue in their mission training.
I'll keep you updated if and/or when he can email out.

sbm4latinaz
2005-09-15, 02:35 PM
They are all red states down there... You think Bush would have really wanted to take care of them in something like this. This will be bad for the republican party...

I don’t understand why the people are shooting at the choppers that come in to supply them, take them out, and try to repair the levees. Just because they stole them selves some new guns doesn’t mean they have to use them.


Well if I'm on my roof and see the same chopper past by me 10 times trying to fix a damb , I'd shoot at him too.
PEOPLE BEFORE PROPERTY GUYS!!!!!!
Ok I'm calm now .

CaptainJSparrow
2005-09-16, 09:08 PM
A friend sent these to me as a joke...thought I'd share'em with ya'll.



Things I have learned from watching the news on TV during the last eight days:

The hurricane only hit black family's property.

New Orleans was devastated and no other city was affected by the hurricane.

Mississippi is reported to have a tree blown down.

New Orleans has no white people.

The hurricane blew a limb off a tree in the yard of an Alabama resident.

When you are hungry after a hurricane, steal a big screen TV.

The hurricane did 23 billion dollars in improvements to New Orleans:
now the city is welfare, looters, and gang free... and they are in your city.

White folks don't make good news stories.

Don't give thanks to the thousands that came to help rescue you, instead bitch because the government hasn't given you a debit card yet.

Only black family members got separated in the hurricane rescue efforts.

Ignore warnings to evacuate and the white folks will come get you and give you money for being stupid